How do you appeal an automatic Self Assessment late filing penalty?
A £100 Self Assessment late filing penalty can be cancelled if you had a reasonable excuse and acted promptly once it ended. This article explains the 30-day appeal window, the Perrin test HMRC applies, and the review and tribunal route if HMRC refuses.
Short answer: file the overdue return first, then appeal within 30 days of the date printed on the penalty notice — online through your personal tax account, or by post on Form SA370 (SA371 for partnerships). HMRC operationally allow 37 days to cover printing and postage. To succeed you must show, on the balance of probabilities, that you had an objectively reasonable excuse and that you filed without unreasonable delay once it ended. If you did not need to file at all, ask HMRC to withdraw the notice instead — that cancels the penalty without any reasonable excuse argument. [Source 1][Source 2][Source 3]
The penalty you are appealing
Schedule 55 penalties for a late Self Assessment return build in four stages, even where no tax is due: [Source 1]
| Stage | Trigger (online return) | Penalty added | Cumulative on a £0-tax return |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initial fixed penalty | 1 February (day after the 31 January deadline) | £100 | £100 |
| Daily penalties | 1 May to 29 July (90 days at £10 per day) | £900 | £1,000 |
| 6-month further penalty | 1 August (greater of 5% of tax due or £300) | £300 | £1,300 |
| 12-month further penalty | Following 1 February (greater of 5% or £300 where information was not deliberately withheld) | £300 | £1,600 |
Where information was deliberately withheld, the 12-month percentage rises to 70% of the tax liability (deliberate but not concealed) or 100% (deliberate and concealed), subject to disclosure reductions. Before 2010/11 the £100 penalty was capped at the tax outstanding; from 2010/11 onwards there is no cap, so the £100 applies in full even when no tax is owed. [Source 1][Source 3]
Cumulative Schedule 55 penalties on a £0-tax return
Cumulative Schedule 55 penalties on a £0-tax return
The £100 penalty is only the first stage — but it is also the easiest to appeal, because a single reasonable excuse can cancel the whole chain.
Step by step: making the appeal
1. File the overdue return. HMRC will tell you the appeal cannot be dealt with until the return is filed, and ask you to file and make a fresh appeal. If one document is genuinely unobtainable, file with reasonable provisional or estimated figures rather than waiting. [Source 3]
2. Appeal within 30 days of the notice date (37 days operationally). The clock runs from the issue date printed on the penalty notice, not the day it arrives. You will need the penalty issue date, the date you filed the return, the date you paid any tax, and details of your reasonable excuse. Appeal online through your personal tax account, or post Form SA370 (individuals) or SA371 (nominated partner for a partnership) to Self Assessment, HM Revenue and Customs, BX9 1AS — by tracked delivery, so you can prove posting inside the window. [Source 2][Source 3]
3. Consider paying while you wait. You do not have to pay the penalty while the appeal is pending — it is informally stood over. But if the appeal is rejected, interest runs on the penalty from the date it was due, so paying upfront (repaid with interest if you win) can be the cheaper option. [Source 2][Source 3]
4. If HMRC refuse: review or tribunal. HMRC's refusal letter offers a statutory review by an independent review officer. You have 30 days from that letter to accept the review or notify the appeal directly to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber). Do neither and the appeal is treated as settled in HMRC's favour. If you accept a review and it upholds the penalty, you have 30 days from the review conclusion letter to notify the tribunal. [Source 2]
Appeal and review timeline
Appeal and review timeline
Every taxpayer step in a penalty dispute has a 30-day window — the notice date, not the delivery date, starts the first one.
What counts as a reasonable excuse: the Perrin test
Liability to a late filing penalty does not arise if you satisfy HMRC or the tribunal that you had a reasonable excuse. The Upper Tribunal's four-stage test in Perrin v HMRC [2018] UKUT 156 (TC) is how HMRC decides: [Source 4]
- Establish the asserted facts — what you say happened, including your beliefs, attributes, situation at the time, and what you or others did or failed to do.
- Decide which facts are proven — on the balance of probabilities, meaning more probable than not, on the evidence available. The onus is on you, and you must explain not just what happened but how it detrimentally affected your ability to comply.
- Apply the objective test — viewed objectively, do the proven facts amount to a reasonable excuse for this taxpayer in those circumstances? If so, when did the excuse stop?
- Check prompt remediation — did you remedy the failure without unreasonable delay once the excuse ceased? A good excuse followed by months of inaction fails at this stage.
Usually accepted: emergency hospital admission or debilitating treatment spanning the deadline; severe mental ill-health that objectively impaired your capacity to manage tax affairs; death of a partner, spouse, child or close relative shortly before the deadline; HMRC system outage on 31 January or failed activation code delivery; destruction or theft of records shortly before the deadline; an agent's sudden critical incapacity after you supplied all records in good time. Usually rejected: a brief cold that did not prevent administrative tasks; generalised stress without functional impact; bereavement months earlier while affairs continued normally; leaving Government Gateway registration until the evening of 31 January; being too busy, forgetting the deadline, or not receiving a reminder. [Source 4]
Two express exclusions. Insufficiency of funds is not a reasonable excuse unless attributable to events outside your control — and a shortage of money to pay the bill never prevents filing the return itself, so file on time and arrange Time to Pay for the tax. Reliance on another person (accountant, bookkeeper, spouse) is not a reasonable excuse unless you took reasonable care to avoid the failure: dated evidence that you supplied records well ahead of the deadline and chased progress is what separates a good reliance case from a rejected one. [Source 1][Source 4]
Special circumstances. Even without a reasonable excuse, HMRC can reduce or stay a penalty under paragraph 16 of Schedule 55 where special circumstances apply — uncommon or exceptional factors, or a result contrary to Parliament's compliance intention. HMRC consider special reduction whenever an appeal against an automated penalty is received, whether or not you cite it. [Source 1]
If you did not need to file at all
Do not argue reasonable excuse if the real answer is that no return was due. Ask HMRC to withdraw the notice to file under section 8B of the Taxes Management Act 1970: when HMRC agree, the Schedule 55 penalties for that return are cancelled automatically, with no excuse to prove. The request must normally be made within two years of the end of the tax year (5 April 2027 for 2024/25, 5 April 2028 for 2025/26). How to cancel Self Assessment when your income drops [Source 6]
Partnerships
If a partnership return is filed late, every partner is personally liable for the £100 penalty. The appeal must be brought by the nominated (representative) partner or the partnership's authorised agent, on Form SA371 or online, through the partnership record — and that single appeal counts for every partner. [Source 3]
Worked example: Amina, 2024/25, England (illustrative)
Amina works part-time (£18,570 PAYE salary, £1,200 tax deducted) and runs a sole-trader graphic design business (£19,670 turnover, £5,000 expenses, £14,670 profit). It is her first year of self-employment, so she made no payments on account. On 28 January 2026 she suffers an emergency hospital admission (acute appendicitis with complications) and remains incapacitated until 10 May 2026. HMRC issue a £100 penalty notice dated 18 February 2026 (30-day deadline 20 March 2026; 37-day operational window 27 March 2026). Her tax remains unpaid, so a 5% late payment penalty follows on 2 March 2026. Daily filing penalties begin on 1 May 2026. On 15 May 2026 — five days after discharge — she files the return, pays in full, and appeals on Form SA370 with her discharge summary. [Source 1][Source 7]
| Step | Working | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Trading profit | £19,670 − £5,000 | £14,670 |
| Total income | £18,570 + £14,670 | £33,240 |
| Taxable employment income | £18,570 − £12,570 Personal Allowance | £6,000 |
| Income Tax | (£6,000 + £14,670) × 20%, all within the £37,700 basic-rate band | £4,134 |
| Net Income Tax due | £4,134 − £1,200 PAYE | £2,934 |
| Class 4 NIC | (£14,670 − £12,570) × 6% | £126 |
| Class 2 NIC | Profits above the small profits threshold, treated as paid | £0 |
| Balancing payment | £2,934 + £126 | £3,060 |
| Late filing penalties | £100 + 14 days (1–14 May) × £10 | £240 |
| Late payment penalty | £3,060 × 5% (30 days late) | £153 |
| Pre-appeal total | £3,060 + £240 + £153 | £3,453 |
| After successful appeal | All £393 of penalties cancelled; interest on late-paid tax is separate and not a penalty | £3,060 |
Note the late-appeal point: Amina's appeal on 15 May is itself outside the 30/37-day window — but it must be accepted, because the same incapacity that excuses the late filing also excuses the late appeal, and she acted within five days of it ending. The tribunal, if it came to it, could also accept a late appeal where the interests of justice require it. [Source 5]
Common mistakes
Appealing before filing. HMRC cannot deal with the appeal until the return is in. File first, then appeal. [Source 3]
Counting from the delivery date. The 30 days run from the issue date printed on the notice. Check the notice itself. [Source 3]
Leaving a gap after the excuse ends. A hospital discharge on 10 February followed by filing in June, with no ongoing incapacity, fails the "without unreasonable delay" stage. [Source 4]
Confusing inability to pay with inability to file. File on time even if you cannot pay; the return costs nothing to submit, and Time to Pay covers the bill. [Source 1]
Blaming an accountant with no evidence of your own care. "My accountant forgot" is rejected without dated proof that you supplied records in good time and chased progress. [Source 1][Source 4]
Arguing reasonable excuse when withdrawal is available. If no return was due, section 8B withdrawal cancels the penalty outright — a stronger and simpler route. [Source 6]
Frequently asked questions
Can I appeal if I owe £0 tax or am due a refund?
Yes, if you have a reasonable excuse — or if no return was due and you seek withdrawal. Owing £0 tax is not itself a ground, because from 2010/11 the £100 penalty is not capped at the tax due. [Source 1][Source 3]
What if I miss the 30-day appeal deadline?
Ask HMRC to accept the appeal late: they must do so if you had a reasonable excuse for the delay and appealed without unreasonable delay after it ended. If they refuse, apply to the First-tier Tribunal, which can accept a late appeal where the interests of justice require it. [Source 5]
Do I have to pay the penalty before HMRC decides?
No — it is informally stood over while the appeal is pending. But if you lose, interest runs from the penalty's due date, so paying upfront can be cheaper. [Source 2][Source 3]
Does a filing appeal also cancel late payment penalties and interest?
Not automatically — filing penalties (Schedule 55) and payment penalties (Schedule 56) are separate charges, though one appeal can cover both where the same excuse prevented filing and payment, and HMRC assess each obligation separately. Late payment interest is not a penalty and cannot be appealed on reasonable excuse grounds. [Source 2]
How does Making Tax Digital change the £100 penalty?
From 6 April 2026, sole traders and landlords mandated into Making Tax Digital for Income Tax (income over £50,000 from 2026/27; over £30,000 from 2027/28) move to points-based late submission penalties: one point per late submission, and a £200 penalty only at the threshold — 2 points for annual obligations, 4 for quarterly. Points and penalties remain appealable on reasonable excuse grounds. Taxpayers outside MTD stay on Schedule 55. [Source 8]
Sources
Numbers in square brackets refer to the sources below. All accessed 30 October 2026.
- Finance Act 2009, Schedule 55 (penalty for failure to make returns) — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, Appeal a Self Assessment penalty for late filing or late payment — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Self Assessment Manual, SAM10080: appeal against a late filing penalty — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Compliance Handbook, CH160900: how to establish if there is a reasonable excuse (Perrin four-stage test) — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Appeals, Reviews and Tribunals Guidance, ARTG2240: late appeals — (opens external site) ↩
- Finance Act 2013, Schedule 51, paragraph 3 (inserting section 8B into the Taxes Management Act 1970) — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, Income tax rates and Personal Allowances — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, Penalties for late submission (points-based regime) — (opens external site) ↩
Please note: This article is general information about UK tax rules, not personal financial advice. Whether a penalty can be cancelled depends on your full circumstances, the evidence you can provide, and HMRC's or the tribunal's judgement on the facts. Figures are stated for 2024/25 to 2026/27 unless another period is given, and thresholds, rates and time limits can change at future fiscal events.
Please note: This article is general information only, based on our understanding of the rules at the date it was last updated. It is not advice and should not be relied on for your own circumstances. Rules and rates change, so please speak to us or another qualified adviser before acting.
Want to talk it through?
Email us with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we’ll get back to you to arrange a free consultation.
Book a free consultation