Self-employed

How does the MTD ITSA penalty points system actually work?

How MTD ITSA penalty points work: one point per missed deadline, a £200 penalty at 4 points, the 2026-27 soft landing, how points expire, and how late payment penalties differ.

Short answer: missing a deadline earns you one penalty point, not an immediate fine. Points build up per group of returns, and when you reach 4 points for quarterly returns, HMRC charges £200 — and a further £200 for each later missed deadline while you stay at 4 points. Points below the threshold expire after 24 months; at the threshold, you clear them only with 12 months of on-time filing plus all outstanding returns.[Source 1]

The regime is Schedule 24 to the Finance Act 2021. It replaced the old fixed-penalty system for MTD taxpayers — under the previous Self Assessment rules, a return filed even one day late drew an immediate £100 penalty. Late payment is a separate regime under Schedule 26, and deliberate withholding is under Schedule 25; this article covers all three so you can tell them apart.[Source 1][Source 2][Source 3]

Who is in the points system?

The points system applies to taxpayers mandated into MTD for Income Tax: individuals with qualifying income — gross self-employment and property income, before expenses — over £50,000 (2024-25 return) from 6 April 2026, over £30,000 (2025-26) from 6 April 2027, and over £20,000 (2026-27) from 6 April 2028.[Source 5]

Qualifying income is the gross figure. Allowances do not reduce it: the £1,000 trading allowance and £1,000 property allowance are applied against profit, not against the gross receipts tested for MTD. Employment income (PAYE), dividends, savings interest and pensions do not count, and partnership income as an individual partner is currently excluded.[Source 5] So a director with only a salary and dividends stays outside MTD and under the existing Self Assessment penalty rules, while a full-time employee with £35,000 of gross rent is caught from Phase 2 (April 2027).

Once mandated, you normally stay in MTD until your qualifying income has been below the threshold for three tax years in a row and you tell HMRC you wish to leave. People who cannot reasonably use digital tools — because of age, disability, location or religion — can apply for a digital-exclusion exemption.[Source 6][Source 13][Source 15]

How does a point arise?

Under Schedule 24, if you fail to make a return on or before its due date, you are liable to one penalty point for the group of returns it belongs to. HMRC must notify you of the point, identifying the failure.[Source 1][Source 7][Source 8] For MTD taxpayers, the quarterly group covers both the four quarterly updates and the Final Declaration.

Standard quarterly deadlines (each one month and two days after the quarter ends):

QuarterStandard periodFiling deadline
Q16 April – 5 July7 August
Q26 July – 5 October7 November
Q36 October – 5 January7 February
Q46 January – 5 April7 May
Final Declaration6 April – 5 April31 January (following year)

MTD ITSA quarterly update deadlines

MTD ITSA filing deadlines7 August: Q1 update due. Quarter 6 April – 5 July; 7 November: Q2 update due. Quarter 6 July – 5 October; 7 February: Q3 update due. Quarter 6 October – 5 January; 7 May: Q4 update due. Quarter 6 January – 5 April; 31 January: Final Declaration due. For the tax year just ended7 AugustQ1 update dueQuarter 6 April – 5 July7 NovemberQ2 update dueQuarter 6 July – 5 October7 FebruaryQ3 update dueQuarter 6 October – 5 January7 MayQ4 update dueQuarter 6 January – 5 April31 JanuaryFinal Declaration dueFor the tax year just endedMTD ITSA filing deadlines7 August: Q1 update due. Quarter 6 April – 5 July; 7 November: Q2 update due. Quarter 6 July – 5 October; 7 February: Q3 update due. Quarter 6 October – 5 January; 7 May: Q4 update due. Quarter 6 January – 5 April; 31 January: Final Declaration due. For the tax year just ended7 AugustQ1 update dueQuarter 6 April – 5 July7 NovemberQ2 update dueQuarter 6 July – 5 October7 FebruaryQ3 update dueQuarter 6 October – 5 January7 MayQ4 update dueQuarter 6 January – 5 April31 JanuaryFinal Declaration dueFor the tax year just ended

MTD ITSA filing deadlines. Quarterly updates fall due on 7 August, 7 November, 7 February and 7 May, with the Final Declaration due the following 31 January. Source: [Source 1].

You can elect calendar quarters instead, which moves the deadlines — confirm the exact dates in your software before your first update, as the first-year dates differ because MTD obligations start on 6 April.

One point per deadline, even with several businesses

If you have a sole trade and a rental property, you file separate quarterly updates for each business. But if returns in the same group share a deadline, all failures at that deadline together earn a maximum of one point: file your trade update on time and your property update late, and you get one point; file both late, and you still get only one point for that quarter.[Source 1] MTD ITSA points are also kept entirely separate from VAT penalty points.[Source 11]

The 4-point threshold and the £200 penalty

For quarterly filers the maximum is 4 points. The moment a failure takes you to 4 points, you are liable to a £200 penalty — and every later failure while you remain at 4 points triggers a further £200 penalty.[Source 1] Paying the £200 does not reset your points.

From a missed deadline to clearing 4 penalty points

MTD penalty points journeyMiss a deadline: 1 penalty point. Per deadline, per group of returns; Reach 4 points: £200 penalty. A further £200 for each later failure at 4 points; Below 4 points: Points expire after 24 months. From the month after the failure; At 4 points: Points clear only after 12 months on time. Plus all returns due in the previous 24 monthsMiss a deadline1 penalty pointPer deadline, per group of returnsReach 4 points£200 penaltyA further £200 for each later failure at 4 pointsBelow 4 pointsPoints expire after 24 monthsFrom the month after the failureAt 4 pointsPoints clear only after 12 months on timePlus all returns due in the previous 24 monthsMTD penalty points journeyMiss a deadline: 1 penalty point. Per deadline, per group of returns; Reach 4 points: £200 penalty. A further £200 for each later failure at 4 points; Below 4 points: Points expire after 24 months. From the month after the failure; At 4 points: Points clear only after 12 months on time. Plus all returns due in the previous 24 monthsMiss a deadline1 penalty pointPer deadline, per group of returnsReach 4 points£200 penaltyA further £200 for each later failure at 4pointsBelow 4 pointsPoints expire after 24 monthsFrom the month after the failureAt 4 pointsPoints clear only after 12 months on timePlus all returns due in the previous 24months

From a missed deadline to clearing 4 points. One point per missed deadline, £200 at 4 points, expiry after 24 months below the threshold — or 12 months of on-time filing once at it. Source: [Source 1].

The 2026-27 soft landing

For the first year, HMRC will not award penalty points for late quarterly updates in 2026-27. That is the whole of the easement — it is not an amnesty.[Source 10][Source 14]

  • Covered: the four quarterly updates for 2026-27 (due 7 August 2026, 7 November 2026, 7 February 2027 and 7 May 2027).
  • Not covered: the Final Declaration for 2026-27, due 31 January 2028 — a late Final Declaration earns a point even in the soft-landing year.
  • Time-limited: from 6 April 2027, every late quarterly update and late Final Declaration earns a point. Taxpayers who join in April 2027 get the same first-year easement for their 2027-28 quarterly updates.[Source 14]

Late payment penalties and interest are not paused by the soft landing (see below).

How do points expire or reset?

It depends on whether you have reached the 4-point threshold.[Source 1]

Below the threshold (1 to 3 points)

Each point expires at the end of 24 months beginning with the first day of the month after the month in which the failure occurred — provided you are still below the maximum when that period ends.[Source 1]

At the threshold (4 points)

Points no longer expire with time alone. All of them expire together only when two conditions are both met: you have made every return in the group on time for 12 months, and you have made all returns in the group whose due date fell in the previous 24 months.[Source 1] If you miss a deadline during the 12-month compliance period, a further £200 penalty is charged and the clock restarts.

Moving between groups

If you change filing frequency, Schedule 24 adjusts your points to the new group's threshold: moving from the quarterly group (maximum 4) to the annual group (maximum 2) deducts 2 points, so 3 quarterly points become 1 annual point rather than an instant breach.[Source 1]

Late payment penalties are separate: Schedule 26

Points punish late filing. Late payment is punished under Schedule 26, which applies to balancing payments and amounts due after an amendment or assessment — not to payments on account.[Source 2]

The percentages were increased following the Spring Statement 2025. For MTD ITSA they are:[Source 2][Source 9][Source 12][Source 18]

PaidPenalty for 2026-27Penalty from 2027-28
Within 15 days of the due dateNo penaltyNo penalty
16 to 30 days lateNo penalty in your first MTD year (30-day grace); otherwise 3% of the tax unpaid at day 154% of the tax unpaid at day 15
31 days or more late3% of the tax unpaid at day 15, plus 3% of the tax unpaid at day 30, plus 10% a year charged daily from day 314% of the tax unpaid at day 15, plus 4% of the tax unpaid at day 30, plus 10% a year charged daily from day 31

MTD late-payment penalty percentages

MTD late-payment percentagesLate-payment penalties: 3% at day 15 and 3% at day 30 in 2026-27; 4% and 4% from 2027-28; plus 10% a year charged daily from day 31.2026-27: 15 days late3%3%2026-27: 30 days late3%3%2027-28: 15 days late4%4%2027-28: 30 days late4%4%Daily penalty from day 31 (both years)10%10%MTD late-payment percentagesLate-payment penalties: 3% at day 15 and 3% at day 30 in 2026-27; 4% and 4% from 2027-28; plus 10% a year charged daily from day 31.2026-27: 15 days late3%3%2026-27: 30 days late3%3%2027-28: 15 days late4%4%2027-28: 30 days late4%4%Daily penalty from day 31 (both years)10%10%

MTD late-payment penalty percentages. Fixed penalties of 3% and 3% in 2026-27, 4% and 4% from 2027-28, plus 10% a year charged daily from day 31. Source: [Source 2].

In your first year under the new late-payment regime, HMRC will not charge the first penalty if you pay in full — or agree a Time to Pay arrangement — within 30 days of the due date.[Source 18]

Late payment interest

Interest is charged on top of any penalty, from the day after the due date, with no grace period. Since 6 April 2025 it runs at the Bank of England base rate plus 4 percentage points (previously base rate plus 2.5%). The current rate is 7.75% from 9 January 2026, reflecting a base rate of 3.75%; it moves whenever the base rate moves.[Source 4]

Time to Pay

Agreeing a Time to Pay arrangement with HMRC in time can prevent late-payment penalties from building up, although interest normally continues during the arrangement. If an agreed arrangement is broken, penalties can be applied as if it had never existed.[Source 2][Source 18]

Failing to keep digital records: up to £3,000

MTD requires digital records kept in MTD-compatible software, with data moving between systems through digital links — not retyped by hand. If a compliance check finds serious or repeated record-keeping failures, HMRC can charge a penalty of up to £3,000. Unlike points, this penalty is not automatic.[Source 11][Source 14]

Deliberately withholding information: Schedule 25

Deliberate non-compliance is punished far more heavily than lateness. If you deliberately fail to file a return in order to withhold information HMRC needs to assess your tax, Schedule 25 charges a percentage of the tax that would have been shown in the return, subject to a £300 minimum. Paragraph 3 sets the percentages and paragraph 4 explains the information categories.[Source 3]

BehaviourCategory 1 (domestic / cooperative territory)Category 2Category 3 (non-cooperative territory)
Deliberate but not concealed70%105%140%
Deliberate and concealed100%150%200%

The penalty can be reduced if you disclose the withheld information to HMRC, with larger reductions for unprompted disclosure — telling HMRC before they had reason to discover the failure — than for prompted disclosure.[Source 3]

Appeals, reasonable excuse and special reduction

You can appeal against the award of a penalty point and against any £200 penalty, under Schedule 24.[Source 1]

Reasonable excuse

No point or penalty arises if you satisfy HMRC — or the First-tier Tribunal on appeal — that you had a reasonable excuse for the failure. The law expressly limits what counts: insufficiency of funds is not a reasonable excuse unless it was caused by events entirely outside your control, and relying on someone else (such as an agent) is not an excuse unless you took reasonable care to avoid the failure.[Source 1] Tribunals commonly accept sudden severe illness, bereavement of a close relative, or catastrophic loss of records such as fire or flood; unexpected computer or software failure while preparing a return can also qualify, provided you file promptly once the system is restored.[Source 16][Source 17]

Special reduction for late payment penalties

For late-payment penalties, Schedule 26 gives HMRC discretion to reduce a penalty where there are special circumstances. Ability to pay does not count as a special circumstance, and neither does the argument that an overpayment by another taxpayer balances the loss. On appeal, the Tribunal can only interfere with HMRC's special-reduction decision if it was legally flawed.[Source 2]

Worked examples

Example 1: points and the soft landing

Taxpayer A, a self-employed consultant mandated into MTD ITSA for 2026-27:

  • Q1 2026-27 update (due 7 August 2026): filed 3 weeks late. Soft landing applies: 0 points.
  • Q2 to Q4 updates: filed on time. 0 points.
  • 2026-27 Final Declaration (due 31 January 2028): filed 10 days late. The soft landing does not cover Final Declarations: 1 point.
  • Q1 2027-28 update (due 7 August 2027): filed late. The soft landing has expired: 1 point. Total: 2 points.

Taxpayer A is halfway to the 4-point threshold. Those points expire 24 months after their respective failures, provided A does not reach 4 points first.[Source 1]

Example 2: late payment arithmetic

Taxpayer B owes a £10,000 balancing payment for 2026-27, due 31 January 2028. B agrees no Time to Pay arrangement and pays in full 50 days late, on 21 March 2028.

  • Day 15 (15 February 2028): under the first-year concession, no penalty for being up to 30 days late.
  • Day 31 (2 March 2028): the debt is still unpaid, so the fixed penalties trigger: 3% of the £10,000 unpaid at day 15 = £300, plus 3% of the £10,000 unpaid at day 30 = £300. Total fixed penalty: £600.
  • Daily penalty: from day 31 to payment (20 days) at 10% a year: £10,000 × 10% × (20 ÷ 365) = £54.79.
  • Interest: from the day after the due date to payment (50 days) at the current rate of 7.75% (base rate 3.75% + 4%): £10,000 × 7.75% × (50 ÷ 365) = £106.16. The rate moves with the base rate, so the figure would differ if the base rate changes before payment.

Total late-payment cost: £600 + £54.79 + £106.16 = £760.95 — plus any penalty point if the Final Declaration was also late.[Source 2][Source 4]

Conclusion

The points system tolerates an isolated slip but punishes repetition: one point per missed deadline, £200 at 4 points, and no automatic reset once you reach the threshold. The 2026-27 soft landing removes points for late quarterly updates only — the Final Declaration, late payment penalties, interest and the £3,000 record-keeping penalty all still apply. From 2027-28, every missed deadline counts, so diary the four update dates (7 August, 7 November, 7 February, 7 May) and the 31 January Final Declaration deadline now.

Frequently asked questions

Does a late quarterly update cost £200 straight away?

No. It costs one penalty point. You pay £200 only when a failure takes you to 4 points, and a further £200 for each later failure while you stay at 4 points.[Source 1]

Do late quarterly updates earn points in 2026-27?

No. HMRC will not award points for late quarterly updates in 2026-27. But a late Final Declaration for 2026-27 still earns a point, and the easement ends on 6 April 2027.[Source 14]

If I have two businesses, do I get two points for one missed quarter?

No. Returns in the same group with the same deadline together earn a maximum of one point for that deadline, even if you file both businesses' updates late.[Source 1]

How do I clear 4 points?

File every return in the group on time for 12 months and make all returns due in the previous 24 months. A missed deadline during that compliance period triggers another £200 penalty and restarts the clock.[Source 1]

Are late payment penalties the same as points?

No. Points punish late filing under Schedule 24. Late payment is punished under Schedule 26 with percentage penalties (3% + 3% + 10% a year for 2026-27, 4% + 4% + 10% a year from 2027-28), plus interest at base rate + 4%.[Source 2][Source 4]

Can I appeal a point?

Yes. You can appeal a penalty point and any £200 penalty, including on the ground of reasonable excuse, and HMRC can reduce a late-payment penalty in special circumstances.[Source 1][Source 2]

Book a free consultation

If you are in Making Tax Digital for Income Tax and want to check your penalty position, or you have missed a deadline and are not sure what it costs, we can help. See our services or contact us to book a free consultation, or email us at contact@taxnetwork.uk with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we will call you back as soon as possible. There is no charge and no obligation.

Want to know more? Read MTD for Income Tax quarterly updates: what you send and when, Are joint landlords caught by the MTD ITSA threshold in 2026? and Do I need to file a tax return? Self Assessment rules explained.

Last reviewed: 28 October 2026. We review this article after each Budget.

Disclaimer: This article is general information about UK tax as it stood when it was written and checked (see the date above). It is not advice for your circumstances and does not create a client relationship. Rates, limits and rules change, so check the sources below or speak to a qualified adviser before acting.

Sources

Numbers in square brackets in the article link to the sources below.

All accessed 28 October 2026.

  1. legislation.gov.uk, Finance Act 2021, Schedule 24 (penalties for failure to make returns) — (opens external site) ↩
  2. legislation.gov.uk, Finance Act 2021, Schedule 26 (penalties for failure to pay tax) — (opens external site) ↩
  3. legislation.gov.uk, Finance Act 2021, Schedule 25 (penalties for deliberately withholding information) — (opens external site) ↩
  4. GOV.UK, HMRC interest rates for late and early payments — (opens external site) ↩
  5. GOV.UK, Work out your qualifying income for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax — (opens external site) ↩
  6. GOV.UK, Find out if you can get an exemption from Making Tax Digital for Income Tax — (opens external site) ↩
  7. HMRC internal manual, CH193140: Penalty reform, late filing penalties — (opens external site) ↩
  8. HMRC internal manual, CH193160: Penalty reform, points and penalties — (opens external site) ↩
  9. HMRC internal manual, CH193500: Penalty reform, late payment penalties — (opens external site) ↩
  10. GOV.UK, Edition 2: Ready, Steady, File! — (opens external site) ↩
  11. ICAEW, Making Tax Digital for income tax penalties — (opens external site) ↩
  12. ICAEW, Penalty regime for MTD for income tax becomes clearer (March 2026) — (opens external site) ↩
  13. ICAEW Tax Faculty, TAXguide 04/25: Making Tax Digital for income tax — (opens external site) ↩
  14. Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG), Making Tax Digital penalties — (opens external site) ↩
  15. Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG), Making Tax Digital exemptions — (opens external site) ↩
  16. Association of Taxation Technicians (ATT), Making Tax Digital frequently asked questions — (opens external site) ↩
  17. Association of Taxation Technicians (ATT), Making Tax Digital: an agents' guide on how to get ready — (opens external site) ↩
  18. Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS), Self-assessment penalties: which regime applies to you and your clients for 2025-26 and 2026-27 — (opens external site) ↩

Please note: This article is general information only, based on our understanding of the rules at the date it was last updated. It is not advice and should not be relied on for your own circumstances. Rules and rates change, so please speak to us or another qualified adviser before acting.

Want to talk it through?

Email us with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we’ll get back to you to arrange a free consultation.

Book a free consultation