Company directors

VAT Groups: One Registration for Your Whole Company Group

Two or more companies under common control can register as a single taxable person, so internal charges carry no VAT — but every member is liable for the whole group's VAT.

Two or more eligible companies under common control can elect to be treated as a single taxable person for VAT: one VAT number, one return through a representative member, and supplies between members disregarded — so a management charge from a shared-services company to a sister company carries no VAT at all.[Source 1][Source 2] The price is joint and several liability: every member is liable for the whole group's VAT for the period of its membership.[Source 1][Source 3] Grouping is elective, and it does not suit every group.

What is a VAT group and how does it work?

Section 43 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 lets two or more eligible persons elect to be treated as a single taxable person for VAT.[Source 1] The UK took up the option in Article 11 of the EU VAT Directive (Council Directive 2006/112/EC).[Source 1] The group is taxed through one appointed representative member, which accounts for the whole group's output and input tax on a single return under a single VAT number.[Source 1][Source 2] Each member's existing VAT number is cancelled on joining, and the group number is unchanged by later changes of membership or representative member.[Source 2]

The courts have described a VAT group as a single taxable person "not materially distinguished from a single body corporate" — Kingfisher (VAT Tribunal (1991) VATTR 47; High Court [1994] STC 63).[Source 9] Grouping changes nothing outside VAT: the companies keep their separate legal personality, contracts and balance sheets. It is a VAT election, not a merger, and it can be unwound.

Who can join a VAT group?

Three tests decide eligibility — eligible person, UK establishment and common control — and all three must be met by every member, with the specified-bodies rules adding a fourth hurdle for large groups.[Source 10][Source 11]

A "body corporate" — a company, a limited liability partnership, or a body incorporated by statute or charter — can join, including a non-trading holding company, a dormant company, an intending trader, or a company making only exempt supplies.[Source 10] Since 1 November 2019, under Schedule 18 of the Finance Act 2019, an individual or a partnership can also join, but only if it controls all the other members, carries on a business by making supplies, and is established in the UK or has a UK fixed establishment in relation to that business.[Source 12][Source 13] A partnership therefore cannot join as a subordinate beneath a corporate parent, though one at the apex of a corporate structure can group with its wholly controlled subsidiaries.[Source 13]

Establishment means a central administration or principal place of business in the UK, or a fixed establishment — a permanent presence with sufficient human and technical resources to make or receive supplies. A registered office alone is not enough.[Source 10] The UK uses a "whole establishment" model: once an entity qualifies through a UK fixed establishment or head office, the whole entity — including its overseas branches — comes inside the group. HM Treasury has consulted on moving to an establishment-only model and on compulsory grouping, and grouping remains elective; the Upper Tribunal confirmed in Barclays in 2026 that the whole-entity approach is a fundamental feature of the UK rules.[Source 2][Source 14]

Control is defined by section 43AZA, by reference to the Companies Act 2006 definition of holding company and subsidiary: a person controls a body corporate if it holds a majority of the voting rights, can appoint or remove a majority of the board, or controls a majority of the voting rights alone under an agreement with other members.[Source 5][Source 15] All members must be controlled by one of the members or by a single person outside the group. The controller need not join — an overseas parent without a UK fixed establishment is barred from joining — yet it can still link its UK sister subsidiaries into a valid group.[Source 15] A joint venture in which two unrelated shareholders each hold 50% fails the single-controller requirement.[Source 15]

Large partially exempt groups face the specified-bodies regime, made by the VAT (Groups: Eligibility) Order 2004 under the Treasury's order-making power in section 43AA.[Source 16] A company is a specified body if four conditions are all met: the group's supplies to persons outside the group exceeded £10 million in the preceding year or are expected to in the coming year; the entity is partly owned or managed by a third party, or is the sole general partner of a limited partnership; it carries on a relevant business activity — supplies to other group members that would carry VAT if un-grouped and on which the recipient cannot fully recover input tax; and it is not an excepted body, such as a registered charity, a pension scheme trustee, or the body controlling all the other members.[Source 11][Source 11] A specified body is barred unless it satisfies both the Benefits Condition — no more than 50% of the activity's benefits accrue to third parties, with charges above open market value counting as benefits — and the Group Accounts Consolidation Condition, under which the controlling person consolidates the specified body as a subsidiary and no third party does so.[Source 16][Source 11]

How does grouping remove VAT on management charges?

The commercial case usually starts with the shared-services company. A group that centralises human resources, IT, finance and legal work in one company and recharges the cost to its operating subsidiaries creates a VAT charge on every recharge. Salaries carry no VAT when paid directly to employees, but once a separately registered service company recharges those staff costs as a management service, the whole gross recharge — including the embedded salary cost — attracts output tax at 20% under section 4 of the 1994 Act.[Source 17] A fully taxable recipient reclaims that VAT, so the cost is only cash-flow timing. But a partially exempt recipient — an insurer, a bank, a fund manager, a healthcare provider, a property investment company — cannot recover all of it, and the VAT on the embedded payroll becomes a permanent, irrecoverable cost.[Source 1]

Grouping removes the charge altogether. Under section 43(1)(a), any supply of goods or services by one member of the group to another is disregarded, so no VAT is accounted for on inter-company management charges, shared-service recharges, intra-group royalties or internal property leases, and no VAT invoices may be issued for them.[Source 1][Source 2] Input tax is incurred only once, on external third-party supplies bought by the group, which are deemed to be purchased by the representative member.[Source 2]

Grouping also re-engineers partial exemption. Residual input tax is recovered by reference to the ratio of taxable to total supplies under section 26, and intra-group exempt supplies — such as exempt rent charged by a group property company to a trading subsidiary — are disregarded, so they no longer dilute the group's recovery fraction.[Source 2][Source 2] But the de minimis limit then applies once to the aggregated group rather than per company, so grouping several subsidiaries that individually qualify as de minimis can push the combined group over the threshold.[Source 2] The same aggregation applies to the Cash Accounting, payments-on-account and error-correction limits, and a group is barred from the Annual Accounting Scheme and excluded from the Flat Rate Scheme — with a 24-month bar even for a business merely eligible to join an existing group.[Source 2][Source 6] In social housing, grouping a taxable development subsidiary with an exempt housing association can put Cost Sharing Exemption eligibility at risk; the National Housing Federation put that cost at up to £4.6 million a year if grouping were made compulsory — not a cost of voluntary grouping.[Source 18]

When does the disregard not apply?

The section 43(1)(a) disregard is not absolute. Four situations need care, and only the first is a genuine statutory exclusion from the disregard itself.

The first is the bought-in services charge in sections 43(2A) to 43(2E). Because the UK uses the whole-establishment model, an overseas branch with a UK fixed establishment can join a UK VAT group — and without a counterweight, a partially exempt UK bank or insurer could have its overseas branch buy IT or consultancy services locally free of UK VAT and recharge them intra-group to the UK head office under the disregard. Section 43(2A) blocks that by excluding the intra-group supply from the disregard where the supplier was supplied with Schedule 5 services while belonging outside the UK and those services were used for the intra-group supply. The representative member must then account for output tax — under section 43(2B) the supply is treated as made by the representative member to itself, and the general reverse charge on services received from abroad is section 8, not section 81.[Source 1][Source 19] Under paragraph 8A of Schedule 6 (Finance Act 2012, section 200, codifying Extra-Statutory Concession 3.2.2), the charge is calculated only on the external bought-in cost if the representative member satisfies HMRC as to the value of each bought-in supply, so the branch's internal salary cost and mark-up stay disregarded unless HMRC directs an open market value — which must be given within three years of the supply and is appealable.[Source 20][Source 2] The charge does not apply to exempt supplies or where the place of supply is not the UK under the general rule, and there is a trifling threshold of £7,500 of output tax a year.[Source 2]

The second is Skandia: where an overseas establishment of a UK group member is itself VAT-grouped in an EU member state operating an establishment-only regime, that establishment is a separate taxable person, and supplies between it and the UK group fall outside the disregard altogether.[Source 2] The third concerns goods in Northern Ireland: under the Windsor Framework arrangements, goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland between members, and goods located in Northern Ireland supplied between members, are chargeable unless both members are established there or have a fixed establishment there.[Source 2]

The fourth is Schedule 9A, an anti-avoidance direction power (Finance Act 1996): HMRC may direct that a company be included in or excluded from a group, or that a particular intra-group supply not be disregarded — subject to restrictions and a six-year time limit, not a self-executing exception.[Source 21][Source 2] Thorn and Svenska were decided on time-of-supply principles, not under Schedule 9A.[Source 7]

What is the Prudential trap on leaving a group?

The most expensive mistake in VAT grouping is leaving a group with intra-group charges still outstanding. On 11 September 2025 the Supreme Court decided The Prudential Assurance Company Ltd v HMRC [2025] UKSC 34, unanimously, and the lesson is now settled law.[Source 7]

Silverfleet Capital managed Prudential's with-profits fund from 2002 while both were members of the same VAT group. Its pay had two parts: quarterly management fees, invoiced and paid while grouped and undisputedly disregarded, and contingent success fees payable only if specified sub-funds beat a benchmark. On 8 November 2007 Silverfleet was bought out, stopped managing the fund, and left the group. In 2014 and 2015 the hurdle rate was passed, and between 16 January 2015 and 11 July 2016 Silverfleet invoiced success fees totalling £9,330,805.92, charging 20% output VAT — £1,866,161.18 that Prudential, as a partially exempt insurer, largely could not recover.[Source 7]

Prudential argued that the services had all been physically performed while the two companies were a single taxable person, so the fees were consideration for an intra-group supply that must be disregarded. The First-tier Tribunal agreed on 26 February 2021, but the Upper Tribunal reversed on 6 March 2023 and the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on 26 March 2024. The Supreme Court agreed: section 43 is not a self-contained code, and the ordinary time-of-supply rules apply first. Under regulation 90 of the VAT Regulations 1995, continuous services whose consideration is determined or payable periodically are treated as separately and successively supplied at the earlier of invoice or payment — and under Article 64 of the EU VAT Directive the chargeable event occurred when the hurdle was passed, in 2014 and 2015, after Silverfleet had left the group. There was nothing during the grouping period for the disregard to bite on.[Source 7][Source 22][Source 7]

The Court followed the route the House of Lords had taken in Thorn, where two subsidiaries contracted to sell goods to a fellow subsidiary with 90% payable on contract and 10% on delivery, then left the group before delivery. The majority held VAT payable on the full consideration, because the goods were delivered and title passed only after the vendors had left the group; the view that the 90% was disregarded and only the 10% taxable was Lord Hoffmann's dissent, not the holding.[Source 7] In Svenska, office services invoiced at £45.3 million after the branch joined the group were supplied at the invoice date, inside the group, so the input tax attributable to the branch's exempt supplies was not deductible.[Source 7]

For anyone planning a de-grouping or a sale, the rule is practical: crystallise, invoice and settle all intra-group charges before the effective date of exit. Where a contingent earn-out or fee cannot be crystallised in advance, the contract needs an explicit VAT gross-up clause allocating the 20% post-exit charge.[Source 7]

Prudential: from group exit to Supreme Court judgment, 2007-2025

Prudential: from group exit to Supreme Court judgment, 2007-20258 Nov 2007: Silverfleet exits the group. Management buy-out; stops managing the fund; 2014-2015: Hurdle rate passed. Success fees become payable for the first time; 16 Jan 2015 - 11 Jul 2016: Success fees invoiced. £9,330,805.92 plus 20% VAT (£1,866,161.18); 26 Feb 2021: First-tier Tribunal rules for Prudential. No VAT due — services performed while grouped; 6 Mar 2023: Upper Tribunal reverses. VAT is payable; Court of Appeal agrees 26 Mar 2024; 11 Sep 2025: Supreme Court dismisses the appeal. Unanimous: time-of-supply rules apply first8 Nov 2007Silverfleet exits the groupManagement buy-out; stops managing the fund2014-2015Hurdle rate passedSuccess fees become payable for the first time16 Jan 2015 - 11 Jul 2016Success fees invoiced£9,330,805.92 plus 20% VAT (£1,866,161.18)26 Feb 2021First-tier Tribunal rules for PrudentialNo VAT due — services performed while grouped6 Mar 2023Upper Tribunal reversesVAT is payable; Court of Appeal agrees 26 Mar 202411 Sep 2025Supreme Court dismisses the appealUnanimous: time-of-supply rules apply firstPrudential: from group exit to Supreme Court judgment, 2007-20258 Nov 2007: Silverfleet exits the group. Management buy-out; stops managing the fund; 2014-2015: Hurdle rate passed. Success fees become payable for the first time; 16 Jan 2015 - 11 Jul 2016: Success fees invoiced. £9,330,805.92 plus 20% VAT (£1,866,161.18); 26 Feb 2021: First-tier Tribunal rules for Prudential. No VAT due — services performed while grouped; 6 Mar 2023: Upper Tribunal reverses. VAT is payable; Court of Appeal agrees 26 Mar 2024; 11 Sep 2025: Supreme Court dismisses the appeal. Unanimous: time-of-supply rules apply first8 Nov 2007Silverfleet exits the groupManagement buy-out; stops managing the fund2014-2015Hurdle rate passedSuccess fees become payable for the firsttime16 Jan 2015 - 11 Jul 2016Success fees invoiced£9,330,805.92 plus 20% VAT (£1,866,161.18)26 Feb 2021First-tier Tribunal rules for PrudentialNo VAT due — services performed whilegrouped6 Mar 2023Upper Tribunal reversesVAT is payable; Court of Appeal agrees 26Mar 202411 Sep 2025Supreme Court dismisses the appealUnanimous: time-of-supply rules apply first

Prudential: from group exit to Supreme Court judgment, 2007-2025

DateEventDetail
8 Nov 2007Silverfleet exits the groupManagement buy-out; stops managing the fund
2014-2015Hurdle rate passedSuccess fees become payable for the first time
16 Jan 2015 - 11 Jul 2016Success fees invoiced£9,330,805.92 plus 20% VAT (£1,866,161.18)
26 Feb 2021First-tier Tribunal rules for PrudentialNo VAT due — services performed while grouped
6 Mar 2023Upper Tribunal reversesVAT is payable; Court of Appeal agrees 26 Mar 2024
11 Sep 2025Supreme Court dismisses the appealUnanimous: time-of-supply rules apply first

Chart spec: Timeline | Title: "Prudential: from group exit to Supreme Court judgment, 2007-2025" | Labels & Values: 8 Nov 2007: Silverfleet exits the group; 2014-2015: Hurdle rate passed; 16 Jan 2015 - 11 Jul 2016: Success fees invoiced £9,330,805.92; 26 Feb 2021: First-tier Tribunal rules for Prudential; 6 Mar 2023: Upper Tribunal reverses; 11 Sep 2025: Supreme Court dismisses the appeal.

Worked example: Harbour Group saves £14,400 a year

Harbour Holdings Ltd is the parent of a small English group and its representative member; its subsidiary, Harbour Insurance Ltd, is a partially exempt insurer. The figures are illustrative, for 2026/27, and the assumptions are stated in full. Harbour Holdings provides management services — finance, human resources and IT — to Harbour Insurance for £120,000 a year. The insurer's partial exemption recovery rate is 40%, and the group's rate is assumed to be 40% as well, so the comparison isolates the charge. The services are performed in the UK by UK staff, so the section 43(2A) charge does not arise, and both companies are eligible and under common control.

Without grouping, the £120,000 charge is a taxable supply, and Harbour Holdings charges output VAT at 20%:

£120,000 × 20% = £24,000

Harbour Insurance pays £144,000 in total and, recovering 40% of its input tax, recovers:

40% × £24,000 = £9,600

The irrecoverable VAT is therefore:

£24,000 − £9,600 = £14,400 a year

Over five years, the group loses £72,000 to irrecoverable VAT on this one internal charge:

5 × £14,400 = £72,000

Inside a VAT group, the same £120,000 charge is disregarded under section 43(1)(a): no VAT, no invoice, and the £14,400 a year stays in the group — £72,000 over five years.[Source 1][Source 2] The members' old VAT numbers are cancelled, one group number is issued, and Harbour Holdings files a single return for the group.[Source 2]

The saving is only as good as the assumptions: if grouping diluted the group's recovery rate or pushed its exempt input tax over the de minimis limit, part of the benefit would be lost — so model the partial exemption position before applying.[Source 2]

Harbour Group: VAT on the £120,000 annual management charge, 2026/27

Harbour Group: VAT on the £120,000 annual management charge, 2026/27VAT charged on the fee, ungrouped: £24,000. VAT recovered at 40%, ungrouped: £9,600. Irrecoverable VAT, ungrouped: £14,400. VAT charged on the fee, grouped: £0. Harbour Group worked example, 2026/27.VAT charged on the fee, ungrouped£24,000£24,000VAT recovered at 40%, ungrouped£9,600£9,600Irrecoverable VAT, ungrouped£14,400£14,400VAT charged on the fee, grouped£0Harbour Group: VAT on the £120,000 annual management charge, 2026/27VAT charged on the fee, ungrouped: £24,000. VAT recovered at 40%, ungrouped: £9,600. Irrecoverable VAT, ungrouped: £14,400. VAT charged on the fee, grouped: £0. Harbour Group worked example, 2026/27.VAT charged on the fee, ungrouped£24,000£24,000VAT recovered at 40%, ungrouped£9,600£9,600Irrecoverable VAT, ungrouped£14,400£14,400VAT charged on the fee, grouped£0

Harbour Group: VAT on the £120,000 annual management charge, 2026/27

£
VAT charged on the fee, ungrouped£24,000
VAT recovered at 40%, ungrouped£9,600
Irrecoverable VAT, ungrouped£14,400
VAT charged on the fee, grouped£0

Chart spec: Horizontal bar chart | Title: "Harbour Group: VAT on the £120,000 annual management charge, 2026/27" | Labels & Values: VAT charged ungrouped: £24,000; VAT recovered at 40% ungrouped: £9,600; Irrecoverable VAT ungrouped: £14,400; VAT charged grouped: £0.

What does joint and several liability really mean?

The statutory price of the disregard is joint and several liability. Under section 43(1), every member is jointly and severally liable for the VAT due from the representative member during its period of membership — not capped at, or apportioned by, the VAT its own trading generated.[Source 1][Source 3] A dormant property-holding company with no external sales can be liable for the whole of a trading sister's output tax debt.[Source 3]

Liability is period-limited, not indefinite. It survives leaving the group, but only for VAT that was due during the member's period of membership, and HMRC must assess within the time limits in section 77: four years after the end of the prescribed accounting period, or twenty years where the loss of VAT was brought about deliberately.[Source 3][Source 8] VAT owed by an entity before it joined stays ring-fenced to that entity under its old registration number.[Source 3]

Because all group transactions are reported on a single return, one member's error becomes a group debt, and a member that discovers a misdeclaration must tell the person completing the group return so the adjustment goes into the group VAT account or a single voluntary disclosure.[Source 2] Late-submission penalty points also sit with the representative member as a single liability for the whole group under Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2021; a business that leaves and registers separately starts with zero points.[Source 23]

Directors face a separate personal regime. Where a grouped company enters, or faces a serious possibility of, insolvency involving tax avoidance or evasion, repeated insolvency, or penalties for facilitating avoidance or evasion, an authorised HMRC officer can issue a Joint and Several Liability Notice under section 100 and Schedule 13 of the Finance Act 2020, making the individual personally liable with the company. The individual has 30 days to accept a review or appeal to the First-tier Tribunal, and where the company is in an insolvency procedure may appeal the company's underlying liability in their own name within 30 days. That regime is separate from section 69D, under which a director is personally liable only for a section 69C VAT-fraud penalty — not for the company's tax debts generally.[Source 24]

The contagion matters most where a company is ring-fenced: a lender to a bankruptcy-remote property company may bar the borrower from joining a wider group, and regulated housing associations keep regulated and commercial entities apart, because grouping exposes ring-fenced cash flows to a sister's VAT debts. Check the facility agreement before grouping a ring-fenced entity — the VAT saving is not worth a loan default.[Source 3]

The same risk drives merger-and-acquisition due diligence. When a buyer acquires a subsidiary from a seller's VAT group, the change of control ends the target's eligibility, but the target carries a secondary liability for the seller's group VAT up to the date it formally leaves. The seller and target should notify HMRC within 30 days and submit form VAT50/51 so the removal takes effect on the completion date. Buyers protect themselves with a pound-for-pound indemnity in the share purchase agreement and tax covenant, backed where the seller looks fragile by an escrow holdback, a bank guarantee, a parent company guarantee, or warranty and indemnity insurance — and by crystallising and settling all intra-group charges before completion, so no Prudential-style liability follows the target.[Source 25][Source 2][Source 7]

How do you apply, and when can HMRC refuse?

Apply on the combined form VAT50/51, uploaded as part of the online VAT registration application and signed or submitted by the representative member; form VAT53 authorises an agent, and form VAT56 changes the representative member. The standalone route is print-and-post: complete VAT50/51 and post it to HMRC using the address on the form.[Source 26][Source 2]

Timing is statutory: HMRC will write within 40 working days of receiving the application to confirm the date it was received, and then has 90 days from receipt to refuse, on ineligibility or for the protection of the revenue. If it does not refuse within 90 days, the application is treated as granted from the date of receipt under section 43B(4)(a); backdating needs HMRC's express agreement under section 43B(4)(b), normally only up to 30 days, to the start of the current accounting period.[Source 25][Source 2] In Dollar Financial, the Upper Tribunal decided only the jurisdiction point — the letter asking to amend a joining date was not a valid section 43B application, so there was no appealable decision.[Source 27]

HMRC may refuse an application, or remove an existing member, only where necessary for the protection of the revenue; its manual confines that power to four grounds: collection of revenue, VAT avoidance, distortion of liability, and lack of co-operation with enquiries. Every decision must be agreed in advance by the VAT Infrastructure and SDIL policy team. A history of avoidance alone is not enough — there must be evidence that the specific application is a vehicle for avoidance — and refusal must not be used as a negotiating tactic in partial exemption discussions.[Source 28] A refusal can be appealed to the First-tier Tribunal under section 83(1)(k). In Barclays, HMRC refused a Delaware corporation's UK branch joining the group on fixed-establishment and revenue-protection grounds; the First-tier Tribunal dismissed the appeal, and the Upper Tribunal did so too.[Source 14]

If grouping does not fit, divisional registration under section 46(1) is the alternative for a single company: a body corporate in several divisions may register in the divisions' names, but only if HMRC sees fit and the whole body is fully taxable or treated as such, and every division must register — even below the £90,000 threshold — for the same tax periods, each with its own number and return.[Source 29][Source 2]

Should your companies form a VAT group?

Should your companies form a VAT group?Common control: grouping is not available without it. UK establishment: a member without it cannot join. Specified body failing a condition: exclude or restructure. Partial exemption or scheme loss: model the cost. Ring-fenced or for sale: keep outside the group. Otherwise grouping is worth modelling in detail.Are all proposed members under commoncontrol?Grouping is not available.NoYesIs every member established in the UK ordoes it have a UK fixed establishment?That member cannot join.NoYesIs any member a specified body that failsthe Benefits or Consolidation Condition?Exclude that member or restructure.YesNoWould grouping breach the group-wide deminimis limit or forfeit a scheme?Model the cost before applying.YesNoIs any member ring-fenced, regulated, orabout to be sold?Keep that member outside the group.YesNoGrouping is worth modelling in detail.Should your companies form a VAT group?Common control: grouping is not available without it. UK establishment: a member without it cannot join. Specified body failing a condition: exclude or restructure. Partial exemption or scheme loss: model the cost. Ring-fenced or for sale: keep outside the group. Otherwise grouping is worth modelling in detail.Are all proposed members under common control?No:Grouping is not available.YesIs every member established in the UK or doesit have a UK fixed establishment?No:That member cannot join.YesIs any member a specified body that fails theBenefits or Consolidation Condition?Yes:Exclude that member or restructure.NoWould grouping breach the group-wide deminimis limit or forfeit a scheme?Yes:Model the cost before applying.NoIs any member ring-fenced, regulated, or aboutto be sold?Yes:Keep that member outside the group.NoGrouping is worth modelling in detail.

Should your companies form a VAT group?

StepQuestionIf yes
1Are all proposed members under common control?Move to step 2. If no, grouping is not available.
2Is every member established in the UK or does it have a UK fixed establishment?Move to step 3. If no, that member cannot join.
3Is any member a specified body that fails the Benefits or Consolidation Condition?Exclude that member or restructure. If no, move to step 4.
4Would grouping breach the group-wide de minimis limit or forfeit a scheme?Model the cost before applying. If no, move to step 5.
5Is any member ring-fenced, regulated, or about to be sold?Keep that member outside the group. If no, grouping is worth modelling.

Chart spec: Flow diagram | Title: "Should your companies form a VAT group?" | Labels & Values: Common control — step 2; UK establishment — step 3; Specified body — exclude or restructure; Partial exemption or schemes — model the cost; Ring-fenced or for sale — keep outside.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming the disregard covers everything. Section 43(2A) bought-in services, supplies to an overseas establishment grouped abroad, Northern Ireland goods, and Schedule 9A directions all fall outside it.
  • Invoicing intra-group charges after a member leaves. Regulation 90 fixes the time of supply at invoice or payment; Prudential shows the cost when the invoice comes years after exit.
  • Treating liability as ending on exit. It survives for VAT due during membership, subject to the section 77 time limits.
  • Forgetting the group-wide de minimis limit and the scheme bars. Grouping can cost more than it saves.
  • Using the wrong form or route. VAT50/51 is one combined form; the standalone route is print-and-post.
  • Assuming a 50/50 joint venture can group. With two unrelated shareholders each holding half, there is no single controller.

Frequently asked questions

Can a sole trader join a VAT group?

Yes, since 1 November 2019 — but only if it controls all the other members, carries on a business by making supplies, and is established in the UK or has a UK fixed establishment. A partnership cannot join as a subordinate beneath a corporate parent.[Source 12][Source 13]

Does grouping remove VAT on all internal charges?

No. The section 43(2A) bought-in services charge, supplies to an overseas establishment grouped abroad, Northern Ireland goods, and Schedule 9A directions all fall outside the disregard.[Source 1][Source 2]

What happens to my VAT number when I join a group?

It is cancelled. The group gets a single VAT number held by the representative member, unchanged by later changes of membership or representative member. If the group is disbanded, each member must re-register.[Source 2]

Can HMRC refuse my application to form a group?

Yes, within 90 days of receipt, on ineligibility or for the protection of the revenue; a refusal can be appealed to the First-tier Tribunal under section 83(1)(k).[Source 25][Source 28]

Does my liability end when I leave the group?

No, not for VAT due during your membership. A former member remains liable for group VAT arising while it was a member, subject to the section 77 time limits — four years, or twenty years where the loss was deliberate.[Source 3][Source 8]

Is grouping always cheaper for a partially exempt business?

Not always. Grouping removes the VAT on internal charges, but the de minimis limit is then tested once for the whole group, the group loses the Annual Accounting and Flat Rate Schemes, and the section 43(2A) charge can apply to bought-in services. Model the whole position first.[Source 2][Source 6]

Sources

  1. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 43 — (opens external site) ↩
  2. HMRC VAT Notice 700/2, "VAT groups and divisional registration" — (opens external site) ↩
  3. HMRC VAT Groups Manual, VGROUPS01500: Joint and several liability — (opens external site) ↩
  4. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 43A — (opens external site) ↩
  5. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 43AA — (opens external site) ↩
  6. HMRC VAT Notice 733, "Flat Rate Scheme for small businesses" — (opens external site) ↩
  7. The Prudential Assurance Company Ltd v HMRC [2025] UKSC 34 — (opens external site) ↩
  8. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 77 — (opens external site) ↩
  9. HMRC VAT Groups Manual, VGROUPS01200: What is a VAT group? — (opens external site) ↩
  10. HMRC VAT Groups Manual, VGROUPS02050: Bodies corporate — (opens external site) ↩
  11. HMRC VAT Groups Manual, VGROUPS02300: Specified bodies — (opens external site) ↩
  12. Finance Act 2019, Schedule 18 — (opens external site) ↩
  13. HMRC VAT Groups Manual, VGROUPS02120: Non-corporate members — (opens external site) ↩
  14. Barclays Service Corporation & Anor v HMRC [2026] UKUT 211 (TCC) — (opens external site) ↩
  15. HMRC VAT Groups Manual, VGROUPS02170: Control — (opens external site) ↩
  16. Value Added Tax (Groups: Eligibility) Order 2004 (SI 2004/1931) — (opens external site) ↩
  17. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 4 — (opens external site) ↩
  18. National Housing Federation, "VAT grouping consultation — NHF response" (2021) — (opens external site) ↩
  19. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 8 — (opens external site) ↩
  20. Value Added Tax Act 1994, Schedule 6 — (opens external site) ↩
  21. Value Added Tax Act 1994, Schedule 9A — (opens external site) ↩
  22. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 6 — (opens external site) ↩
  23. Finance Act 2021, Schedule 24 — (opens external site) ↩
  24. Finance Act 2020, Schedule 13 — (opens external site) ↩
  25. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 43B — (opens external site) ↩
  26. GOV.UK, "Apply for VAT group registration" — (opens external site) ↩
  27. Dollar Financial UK Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKUT 256 (TCC) — (opens external site) ↩
  28. HMRC VAT Groups Manual, VGROUPS06150: Protection of the revenue — (opens external site) ↩
  29. Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 46 — (opens external site) ↩

Numbers in square brackets in the article link to the sources below.

Please note: this article is general information about UK tax law in 2026/27, not personal tax advice; take professional advice before acting.

Please note: This article is general information only, based on our understanding of the rules at the date it was last updated. It is not advice and should not be relied on for your own circumstances. Rules and rates change, so please speak to us or another qualified adviser before acting.

Want to talk it through?

Email us with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we’ll get back to you to arrange a free consultation.

Book a free consultation