VAT on Commercial Property: Option to Tax and Leases
An option to tax lets a landlord charge 20% VAT on commercial rents and recover input VAT — but the election lasts 20 years and changes the VAT on every lease payment that follows.
A landlord who opts to tax a commercial property charges 20% VAT on the rent and can recover the input VAT on buying, refurbishing and running the building. Without the option, the rent is exempt and that input VAT is lost. The trade-off is that the election normally binds the landlord for 20 years, and it changes the VAT treatment of almost every payment under the lease.
How does the option to tax work on commercial property?
By default, the grant, assignment or surrender of any interest in, right over, or licence to occupy commercial land and buildings is exempt from VAT under Group 1 of Schedule 9 to the Value Added Tax Act 1994.[Source 1] The main exception is the freehold sale of a new commercial building or civil engineering work within three years of its completion, which is mandatorily standard-rated at 20%.[Source 2] A building is new for three years from completion — the certificate of practical completion or first full occupation, whichever is first; for civil engineering works, the engineer's certificate or first full use.[Source 2] Once a commercial building is more than three years old, or whenever a leasehold interest is granted at rent, the supply is exempt unless the supplier actively exercises an option to tax.
The option attaches to the person, not the property. An option to tax is personal to the specific VAT-registered business (or person intending to register) in relation to that specific land or building, so a seller's option never carries over to a purchaser, and a freeholder's option does not bind a head tenant who sub-lets part of the premises.[Source 3] [Source 4] A business does not need to own a legal interest in the property at the time it opts.[Source 4]
For VAT purposes, "land" includes any buildings or civil engineering structures permanently affixed to it.[Source 4] Two buildings joined by an internal access or a covered walkway for moving goods and people are treated as a single building — but only if the link existed before completion: a link created after both buildings are completed does not spread the option.[Source 4]
Exercising a valid option requires two stages. First, the business must take a formal decision to opt, and keep a written record showing clear details of the land or buildings and the date the decision was made — board minutes for a company, or a formal decision note for a sole proprietor or partnership.[Source 4] Second, the option acquires legal force only once it is notified in writing to HMRC within 30 days of the effective decision date. Standard notification is on Form VAT1614A, emailed to HMRC's Option to Tax National Unit if the business is VAT-registered, or sent by post, or submitted with the VAT registration application.[Source 4] The temporary 90-day notification window introduced during COVID-19 applied only to decisions made between 15 February 2020 and 31 July 2021; for decisions made from 1 August 2021 onwards, the 30-day rule applies.[Source 5] The form must be signed by an authorised person such as a company director, partner or trustee; if an agent signs, a dedicated letter of authority signed by the client must be attached, because the standard agent authorisation does not confer authority to sign an option to tax notification.[Source 4]
If the decision is made but the 30-day deadline is missed, the option is invalid unless HMRC exercises its discretion to accept a belated notification. HMRC will normally accept one if the taxpayer provides either direct documentary evidence that the decision was made at the relevant time, or evidence that output tax was charged and accounted for and input tax claimed in accordance with the option, together with a written declaration from a responsible person such as a director that the decision was made at the relevant time. HMRC may also accept a late notification in other circumstances depending on the facts.[Source 4]
Since 1 February 2023, following Revenue and Customs Brief 1 (2023), HMRC no longer issues Option to Tax notification receipt letters: an emailed Form VAT1614A receives only an automated response whose timestamp confirms the date HMRC was notified, and postal notifications receive no acknowledgement at all unless HMRC requires further information.[Source 6] HMRC also stopped answering requests asking whether an option to tax is on file, except where the effective date was likely more than six years ago, or where the request comes from an appointed Land and Property Act Receiver or Insolvency Practitioner.[Source 6] A future buyer's solicitor or a tenant's adviser will demand proof of a valid option before accepting a 20% VAT charge. Keep the decision record, the completed Form VAT1614A and the automated HMRC email receipt for a minimum of six years — and as best practice for the life of the option, since an option cannot normally be revoked until at least 20 years have passed.[Source 4] [Source 6]
When do you need HMRC's permission to opt?
A landlord can opt as of right on Form VAT1614A only if the business has made no exempt supplies of the land or building — such as granting an exempt lease or licence — within the 10-year period ending on the date from which the option is to take effect, and does not intend to make any.[Source 4] If the taxpayer has made, or intends to make, any exempt supply of the property during that 10-year lookback window, it must first check whether it satisfies one of the automatic permission conditions in paragraph 5.2 of VAT Notice 742A. Where none is met, the business cannot file Form VAT1614A and must instead apply to HMRC for prior written permission on Form VAT1614H.[Source 4]
Form VAT1614H asks for the details HMRC needs to judge whether the option would give an unfair tax advantage: the total value of exempt supplies made in the last 10 years; whether the property is currently used to make exempt supplies; whether any grants were made for a premium or pre-payment of rent, with dates and values; future plans, including the expected value of taxable supplies; the value of input tax expected on future refurbishment, and what it relates to; and whether the taxpayer wants to recover pre-option input tax.[Source 7] The pre-option period for recovering input tax is normally limited to six months, although HMRC may allow a longer period in some circumstances.[Source 7] The form also asks whether the opter, a person providing finance for the purchase, or a connected person occupies or will occupy the property.[Source 7]
Unlike a standard notification, an application under Form VAT1614H cannot take effect retrospectively: if granted, the option takes effect only from the date of the application or a specified future date.[Source 4]
How long does an option last, and how do you get out of one?
Once notified, an option to tax cannot normally be revoked for 20 years. There are three exits. The first is the six-month cooling-off period. An option can be revoked on Form VAT1614C if less than six months have passed since it took effect, no tax has become chargeable on a supply of the land as a result of the option, no transfer of a going concern has occurred, and one of three further conditions in Section F of Notice 742A is also met — in short, either no extra property input tax was recovered, or it would be accounted back under regulations 107 and 108 of the VAT Regulations 1995, or it was recovered entirely on one capital item and is less than 20% of the total input tax on that item.[Source 4] Input tax having been claimed is therefore not an absolute bar to cooling-off — the second condition expressly contemplates revocation where the tax is accounted back.
The second exit is the six-year automatic lapse. Under paragraph 24 of Schedule 10, an option is treated as revoked if the opter holds no relevant interest in the building or land throughout any continuous period of six years — and only then.[Source 3] If the opter reacquires an interest before six continuous years have elapsed, the option was never revoked, and the 20-year period continues to run from the original effective date; there is no new 20-year clock.[Source 3] [Source 4]
The third exit is revocation after 20 years on Form VAT1614J. Revocation without permission is available if either neither the taxpayer nor any connected relevant associate holds a relevant interest at the date of revocation, or all of conditions 2 to 5 in Section G of Notice 742A are met — including that the land or building does not fall for input-tax adjustment as a capital item, though a capital item is disregarded where the remaining adjustment does not exceed £10,000. HMRC permission to revoke is also available even if Section G is not met, although permission is not granted unless condition 2 is met.[Source 4]
The option to tax lifecycle: the dates that matter
The option to tax lifecycle: the dates that matter
| Date | Milestone |
|---|---|
| Day 0 | Decision to opt to tax, recorded in writing |
| Within 30 days | Notify HMRC on Form VAT1614A |
| 6 months | Cooling-off window closes (Form VAT1614C, with Section F conditions) |
| 6 continuous years | Option lapses automatically only after six years without an interest |
| 20 years | Revocation available on Form VAT1614J |
Chart spec: Timeline | Title: "The option to tax lifecycle: the dates that matter" | Events: Day 0: Decision to opt, recorded in writing. Within 30 days: Notify HMRC on Form VAT1614A. 6 months: Cooling-off window closes (VAT1614C, Section F conditions). 6 continuous years: Option lapses only after six years without an interest. 20 years: Revocation available on Form VAT1614J.
Should you opt to tax?
The financial case for opting is usually straightforward: exempt rents block input-tax recovery, so a landlord who has paid VAT on the purchase price or on refurbishment loses it permanently unless the option is in place. But recovery is not automatic on opting. Full recovery of input tax requires the option — or unequivocal documentary evidence of the intention to opt — to be in place before any supplies of the building are made.[Source 4] Opting after rents have already been charged exempt does not retrospectively unlock the input tax on the purchase.
Whether the 20% charge on the rent is a commercial problem depends on the tenant, not the landlord. A tenant that makes wholly taxable supplies recovers the VAT in full, so the 20% is a cash-flow item, not a cost. A tenant that makes exempt supplies — a bank, an insurer, a charity using the building as an office — cannot recover it, so the VAT becomes a real 20% addition to its rent. A tenant making both taxable and exempt supplies recovers input tax only by attribution under a partial exemption method, so the cost is a proportion, not all or nothing.[Source 8] Before opting, a landlord should therefore know the tenant's VAT profile; opting into a building full of exempt tenants can make the property harder to let.
The sale of the building needs the same care. If the seller has opted and the property is tenanted or let as a going concern, the sale is normally a transfer of a going concern — no supply for VAT purposes and no VAT charged — provided the buyer has opted and notified HMRC, effective on or before the relevant date.[Source 4] The relevant date is normally the date of the transfer, but receipt of a deposit paid in advance of the transfer (unless paid to an independent stakeholder) makes the relevant date earlier than completion, so a buyer who opts only at completion can fail the test.[Source 4] Note also that a freehold sale of a new commercial building is standard-rated independently of any option.[Source 2]
Anti-avoidance can disapply an option, but only grant by grant. Within a VAT group, an option made by one member binds other members as relevant associates for supplies of that property. Under paragraph 12 of Schedule 10, where a property is or is expected to become a Capital Goods Scheme item, the grant is to a connected person, and the occupier will use the property other than wholly or substantially wholly (at least 80%) for eligible purposes — making taxable supplies or activities entitling input-tax credit — the option does not have effect for the supplies arising from that grant.[Source 3] [Source 4] Disapplication for one grant does not taint other grants of the same property. The Capital Goods Scheme test turns on VAT-bearing costs, net of VAT, of £250,000 or more — a £300,000 purchase price alone does not prove a Capital Goods Scheme item, because an exempt purchase with no VAT-bearing costs is not one.[Source 4] Two de minimis rules often decide the point: a development financier (or connected person) occupying 10% or less, and a grantor or connected person occupying 2% or less, are treated as not in occupation.[Source 4]
What VAT applies to dilapidations and surrender payments?
A dilapidations payment — money paid by a tenant for failing to keep the property in repair — is outside the scope of VAT: HMRC's position, restated in Revenue and Customs Brief 2 (2022) with effect from 1 April 2022, is that it is compensation for breach of the lease, not consideration for a supply.[Source 2] [Source 9] Input tax on refurbishment carried out after the dilapidations are settled follows the intended future supplies of the building: wholly recoverable if the building will be let taxable, wholly irrecoverable if it will be let exempt, and apportioned if mixed.[Source 2]
Break fees are different. A payment for early termination made within the terms of the contract is further consideration for the lease, so it follows the lease: standard-rated if the landlord has opted, exempt if not. A payment for termination outside the contract is a supply of the right to terminate, and is standard-rated — unless the fee is clearly punitive, designed to prevent breach rather than to compensate for lost income, in which case it is outside the scope of VAT.[Source 9]
Surrender payments depend on who pays whom. Where the landlord pays the tenant to surrender (a reverse surrender), the tenant's supply is exempt unless the tenant has opted. Where the tenant pays the landlord to accept a surrender, the landlord's supply is exempt unless the landlord has opted.[Source 2] Statutory compensation, for example under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (England and Wales), is outside the scope of VAT.[Source 2]
The direct-tax treatment is a separate question, and it turns on the facts. For the landlord, a dilapidations receipt is income where it fills a hole in rental profits — compensation for the lower rent the property can now command — and capital where it makes good a permanent diminution in the capital value of the reversion. HMRC's manual states the treatment "will depend on the particular circumstances": where the landlord disposes of the property or occupies it himself, the payment is likely to be capital and chargeable to Capital Gains Tax; otherwise it is likely to be a receipt of the property business.[Source 10] The First-tier Tribunal's decision in Thornton illustrates the point: the landlord repaired the building and re-let it, spending over £273,000 on a £250,000 settlement, yet the whole receipt was held capital because it made good a permanent diminution in capital value.[Source 11] Re-letting versus selling is therefore not the dividing line. For the tenant, a dilapidations composition payment is deductible as revenue to the extent it reflects deferred repairs that would have been allowable if done during the lease, and the deduction is not conditional on the landlord actually carrying out the repairs; the capital element is not deductible.[Source 12]
The surrender figures are fixed by HMRC's manual. Where a tenant surrenders a lease on payment of a sum, part is taxed as property income under the short-lease premium formula: property income equals the surrender sum multiplied by (50 − Y) / 50, where Y is the number of complete years (other than the first) in the effective duration of the lease up to the surrender. On HMRC's example, a tenant surrenders a 21-year lease after six years for £50,000: £50,000 × (50 − 5) / 50 = £45,000 is property income, and the remaining £5,000 is a chargeable gain, with no deduction for any part of the freehold cost.[Source 13] [Source 14] Where the lease does not provide for the surrender, the receipt is a capital sum under section 22 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992: on HMRC's figures, remaining base cost £276,000 × £50,000 / £750,000 = £18,400 allowable, giving a gain of £31,600.[Source 13] [Source 15]
Where the landlord pays the tenant to surrender, the payment is capital with no deduction against rental profits, and it is allowable for Capital Gains Tax under section 38(1)(b) only if it is reflected in the state or nature of the property when the landlord disposes of it — not if a new lease is granted on essentially the same terms.[Source 13] A tenant who pays to surrender gets no deduction at all: the payment is capital, the lease being a fixed capital asset, and it is neither enhancement expenditure nor an incidental cost of disposal.[Source 16] The tenant's own disposal of the lease can still produce an allowable loss, because the lease's base cost — including any premium paid — remains in play.[Source 13]
Do not confuse a tenant-paid surrender sum with a reverse premium. HMRC's manual expressly warns that a tenant-paid surrender sum "may be described as a 'reverse premium'. However, it is not a reverse premium of the kind described in CG70830 onwards."[Source 13] The true reverse premium is a sum paid by the landlord to induce the tenant to enter into the lease: it is a revenue receipt for the tenant, and for an investor landlord payer it is capital, with no deduction against rental profits, allowable for Capital Gains Tax only if reflected in the property's state or nature at disposal.[Source 17] [Source 18] Rent-free periods and reduced rents are not reverse premiums. A tenant who pays a premium for a short lease gets matching relief, spread over the receipt period.[Source 19]
Dilapidations damages are capped by section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 — but only for breach of a covenant to keep or put premises in repair, at the diminution in the value of the reversion, and with no damages where the premises would be pulled down or structurally altered. The cap does not apply to reinstatement or redecoration covenants. The 1927 Act and the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 are England and Wales only.[Source 20]
How is this lease payment taxed for VAT?
How is this lease payment taxed for VAT?
| Payment | VAT treatment |
|---|---|
| Dilapidations payment | Outside the scope of VAT |
| Break fee within the contract | Follows the lease: 20% if opted, exempt if not |
| Break fee outside the contract | Supply of the right to terminate: 20% |
| Landlord pays tenant to surrender | Exempt unless tenant opted |
| Tenant pays landlord to surrender | Exempt unless landlord opted |
| Parking with the lease | 20% unless part of a single exempt supply |
Chart spec: Flow | Title: "How is this lease payment taxed for VAT?" | Steps: Dilapidations payment? Yes: Outside the scope of VAT. No: Break fee within the contract? Yes: Follows the lease — 20% if opted, exempt if not. No: Break fee outside the contract? Yes: Supply of the right to terminate — 20%. No: Surrender payment? Yes: Exempt unless the paying party has opted. No: Parking? Yes: 20% unless part of a single exempt supply.
When is parking standard-rated for VAT?
The grant of facilities for parking a vehicle is expressly excluded from the land exemption, so it is standard-rated at 20%.[Source 1] [Source 2] Parking supplied together with commercial premises is usually a single supply that follows the main supply: parking let with an opted building is standard-rated, and parking let with an exempt lease is exempt.[Source 2] In RK Fuels, the lease of a car park area to a car-wash business was held to be a grant of facilities for parking vehicles, made expressly or by necessary implication, and therefore a taxable supply — the area was "for all intents and purposes, a car park", and the tenant had no right to exclude others from the land, so there was no exempt supply of a right over land.[Source 21] The £8,000 assessment was upheld and the appeal dismissed.[Source 21]
Exceptions apply where the supply is of land, not parking: letting land where a parking reference is merely incidental, to a motor dealer for stock, for a market or car boot sale, or to a travelling fair or circus.[Source 2] Residential parking follows the dwelling: parking supplied with a residential letting is exempt with it, subject to the conditions in Notice 742.[Source 2]
What about rent deposits, service charges and insurance recharges?
Taking a rent deposit is not a supply and creates no tax point. If the deposit is drawn down against unpaid rent or dilapidations it becomes further consideration for the lease, standard-rated where the landlord has opted and exempt where it has not; a deposit forfeited and kept as compensation is outside the scope of VAT.[Source 22] [Source 2] Leasehold service charges follow the lease, freehold service charges are standard-rated, and insurance recharges follow the lease. Sub-metered fuel and power supplied with the lease is charged at the 5% reduced rate, and for GB electricity the rate is temporarily 0% from 1 October 2026 to 30 June 2027.[Source 2] [Source 23]
Stamp Duty Land Tax is charged on VAT-inclusive consideration, so opting to tax increases the SDLT bill — unless the option is made after the land transaction has been entered into and the contract provides for it.[Source 24] The Scottish and Welsh equivalents mirror the rule.[Source 25] [Source 26] Finally, if the landlord deregisters (deregistration threshold £88,000; registration threshold £90,000), VAT on retained opted property is due only where the VAT due on the deemed supply exceeds £1,000.[Source 27] [Source 28]
Worked example: Priya's opted office
Priya, a landlord in England, buys a vacant office in 2026/27 for £1,000,000 plus £200,000 VAT and spends £100,000 plus £20,000 VAT refurbishing it. She opts to tax before any supply is made and lets to a firm of solicitors — a wholly taxable tenant — at £80,000 a year. This example is illustrative.
Step 1 — the input VAT. With the option in place before any supplies, Priya recovers the full £220,000 of input VAT (£200,000 + £20,000). Without the option, the whole £220,000 would be irrecoverable, because the rent would be exempt.
Step 2 — the annual output VAT. Priya charges £16,000 of VAT a year on the rent (£80,000 × 20%). The solicitors recover it in full, so it costs them nothing beyond cash flow.
Step 3 — the counterfactual. Had Priya let to an exempt tenant, the same £16,000 a year would have been a real cost to the tenant. The option is worth £220,000 to Priya, but only if the tenant can recover the VAT it creates.
Priya's VAT: what opting to tax is worth
Priya's VAT: what opting to tax is worth
| Item | Amount (£) |
|---|---|
| Input VAT recovered with the option | 220,000 |
| Input VAT lost without the option | 220,000 |
| Annual output VAT on £80,000 rent | 16,000 |
Chart spec: Hbar | Title: "Priya's VAT: what opting to tax is worth" | Labels & Values: Input VAT recovered with the option: £220,000; Input VAT lost without the option: £220,000; Annual output VAT on £80,000 rent: £16,000.
Common mistakes
- Notifying late and assuming the option took effect. An option notified more than 30 days after the decision is invalid unless HMRC accepts a belated notification.
- Opting after exempt rents have started, without permission. A 10-year exempt history means Form VAT1614H, not VAT1614A.
- Treating a dilapidations payment as a taxable supply. It is outside the scope of VAT; charging VAT on it is wrong.
- Calling a tenant-paid surrender sum a reverse premium. A true reverse premium is paid by the landlord to induce the tenant to take the lease.
- Assuming a repurchase revives the option. An option lapses only after six continuous years without an interest; reacquiring inside that period means it was never revoked.
Frequently asked questions
I missed the 30-day deadline to notify HMRC. Is my option lost?
Not necessarily. HMRC will normally accept a belated notification if you provide direct documentary evidence that the decision was made at the relevant time, or evidence that output tax was charged and input tax claimed in accordance with the option, together with a written declaration from a responsible person. But do not rely on discretion: notify within 30 days and keep the automated HMRC email receipt.
Does opting to tax affect the Stamp Duty Land Tax on the purchase?
Yes. SDLT is charged on VAT-inclusive consideration, so a 20% VAT charge on the price increases the SDLT — unless the option is made after the land transaction has been entered into and the contract provides for it. The Scottish and Welsh equivalents mirror the rule.
My tenant is a charity. Should I still opt to tax?
Probably not on that building. A charity that makes exempt supplies cannot recover the 20% VAT on its rent, so the VAT becomes a real cost for it — and where a charity confirms in writing before the supply that it will use the building solely for a relevant charitable purpose, other than as an office, the option is disapplied for that grant.
Sources
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, Schedule 9, Group 1 — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, Land and property (VAT Notice 742) — (opens external site) ↩
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, Schedule 10 — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, Opting to tax land and buildings (VAT Notice 742A) — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, Changes to notifying an option to tax land and buildings during coronavirus (COVID-19) — (opens external site) ↩
- HM Revenue & Customs, Revenue and Customs Brief 1 (2023) — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, Opting to tax land and buildings: Application for permission to opt (VAT1614H) — (opens external site) ↩
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 26 — (opens external site) ↩
- HM Revenue & Customs, Revenue and Customs Brief 2 (2022) — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Property Income Manual, PIM2040 — (opens external site) ↩
- Thornton v Revenue and Customs [2016] UKFTT 767 (TC) — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Business Income Manual, BIM43265 — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Capital Gains Manual, CG71262 — (opens external site) ↩
- Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, section 277 — (opens external site) ↩
- Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992, section 38 — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Business Income Manual, BIM35625 — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Capital Gains Manual, CG70830 — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC Business Income Manual, BIM41060 — (opens external site) ↩
- Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, section 291 — (opens external site) ↩
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, section 18 — (opens external site) ↩
- R K Fuels Ltd v Revenue & Customs [2021] UKFTT 68 (TC) — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC VAT Supply and Consideration Manual, VATSC03360 — (opens external site) ↩
- HM Treasury and HMRC, Budget 2026: Overview of Tax Legislation and Rates (OOTLAR) — (opens external site) ↩
- Finance Act 2003, Schedule 4, paragraph 2 — (opens external site) ↩
- Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Act 2013, Schedule 2, paragraph 2 — (opens external site) ↩
- Land Transaction Tax and Anti-avoidance of Devolved Taxes (Wales) Act 2017, Schedule 4, paragraph 2 — (opens external site) ↩
- GOV.UK, How VAT works: VAT thresholds — (opens external site) ↩
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, Schedule 4, paragraph 8 — (opens external site) ↩
Please note: this article is general information about UK tax law in 2026/27, not personal tax advice; take professional advice before acting.
Please note: This article is general information only, based on our understanding of the rules at the date it was last updated. It is not advice and should not be relied on for your own circumstances. Rules and rates change, so please speak to us or another qualified adviser before acting.
Want to talk it through?
Email us with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we’ll get back to you to arrange a free consultation.
Book a free consultation