Should I use VAT cash accounting or standard accounting?
Standard VAT accounting taxes you on invoices; cash accounting taxes you only when money moves. This article explains who each method suits, the £1.35 million entry and £1.6 million exit limits, how bad debt relief differs, and the cliff edge when you leave the cash scheme.
Short answer: if your customers pay slowly and you usually owe HMRC net VAT, cash accounting protects your cash flow — you do not pay output VAT until the customer pays you, and bad debts never enter the return. If you are paid immediately, regularly reclaim more VAT than you pay, or work mainly under the construction reverse charge, standard accounting is usually better, because cash accounting delays your input VAT reclaims until you pay suppliers. The choice is about timing, not about how much VAT you ultimately pay. [Source 1]
How the two methods differ
| Feature | Standard accounting (default) | Cash accounting (Notice 731) |
|---|---|---|
| Output VAT (Box 1) | Invoice date or supply date, whichever is earlier | Date the customer pays you |
| Input VAT (Box 4) | Date you receive the supplier's VAT invoice | Date you pay the supplier |
| Bad debts | Statutory bad debt relief after 6 months (see below) | Automatic: unpaid sales never enter the return |
| Unpaid supplier invoices | Input VAT reclaimed on invoice, then repaid under s.26A if still unpaid after 6 months | Input VAT never claimed until paid, so no clawback |
| Compatibility | Cannot combine with cash accounting or the flat rate scheme on the same supplies | Compatible with annual accounting; incompatible with the flat rate scheme |
Cash accounting does not change VAT rates, and it does not remove the need for valid VAT invoices. It changes only the tax point — from invoice date to payment date. [Source 1]
Who can join cash accounting?
You can start if you meet all of these conditions: [Source 1]
- You expect taxable supplies (standard, reduced and zero-rated, excluding VAT) of £1.35 million or less in the next 12 months. Do not include exempt supplies or expected sales of capital assets in that estimate.
- You have no VAT returns outstanding.
- You do not owe HMRC money, or you have an arrangement in place to clear what you owe, including surcharges and penalties.
- You have no VAT offence conviction, compounded proceedings, or penalty for VAT evasion involving dishonest conduct in the last 12 months, and HMRC has not denied or withdrawn the scheme from you in the last 12 months.
Businesses registered for less than 12 months can estimate from their VAT 1 registration figures, business plans or pre-registration trading; longer-registered businesses can use the past year's turnover as a guide. If the estimate turns out wrong but had reasonable grounds, HMRC will not penalise you — but keep a record of how you made it, because an estimate with no reasonable basis means immediate removal. [Source 1]
Cash accounting is only available to businesses already VAT-registered. How the VAT registration threshold works
When cash accounting helps, and when it hurts
The deciding question is simple: do your customers take longer to pay you than you take to pay your suppliers, and do you usually owe HMRC money overall?
Cash accounting helps when you give extended credit, suffer many bad debts, or both — HMRC's own list of beneficiaries. A business with 60- or 90-day customer terms stops funding HMRC out of its own pocket while waiting to be paid. [Source 1]
Cash accounting hurts when:
- You are paid immediately. Retail, hospitality and e-commerce businesses collect at the point of sale, so there is no output VAT deferral to gain — but input VAT on 30- to 60-day supplier invoices is still delayed. HMRC lists businesses usually paid as soon as they make a sale as getting no benefit. [Source 1]
- You are usually in a repayment position. Exporters, zero-rated producers and capital-heavy start-ups reclaim more than they pay. Standard accounting refunds input VAT on receipt of the invoice; cash accounting withholds the refund until you have paid the supplier out of your own cash. [Source 1]
- You make continuous supplies of services. HMRC lists these as getting no benefit from the scheme. [Source 1]
- Most of your sales are under the domestic reverse charge (see below): no output VAT is collected from customers anyway, so cash accounting only delays your input reclaims. [Source 1]
When exactly does payment count?
Because the invoice date no longer sets the tax point, the payment date matters — and it depends on how the customer pays: [Source 1]
| Payment method | Output VAT counts when | Input VAT counts when |
|---|---|---|
| Cash (coins or notes) | You are given the money (endorse the customer's invoice copy with amount and date if asked) | You hand over the money (supplier endorses your invoice copy) |
| Bank transfer, standing order, direct debit | Your bank account is credited | Your bank account is debited |
| Credit or debit card | You make out the sales voucher — not when the card provider settles funds to you | You make out the purchase voucher or authorise the transaction |
| Cheque | The later of the date you receive it and the date written on it | The later of the date you send it and the date written on it |
If a card payment or cheque is dishonoured, no VAT is accounted for — or, if already accounted for, adjust under the error-correction rules. Keep a cash book summarising all payments made and received with a separate VAT column, cross-referring every payment to its invoice and to bank statements or paying-in slips. [Source 1]
Part payments. A part payment against a single invoice is taxed proportionately: work out what percentage of the invoice has been paid, and apply that percentage to the VAT on the invoice. A payment that does not relate to a particular supply is allocated to the earliest invoice first, unless the payer specifies otherwise; for invoices at mixed rates, the payment is apportioned across the rates on the invoice. [Source 1]
Bad debt relief under standard accounting
Under standard accounting, an unpaid invoice has already cost you its VAT. Recovery comes only through statutory bad debt relief under section 36 of the VAT Act 1994, and every condition must be met: [Source 2][Source 3]
- You have already accounted for the output VAT and paid it to HMRC.
- You have written the debt off in your day-to-day VAT accounts and transferred it to a separate bad debt account. A general provision for doubtful debts does not count, but writing it off for VAT purposes does not stop you pursuing the debtor commercially.
- The supply was not more than its customary selling price.
- The debt has not been paid, sold or factored under a valid legal assignment.
- At least 6 months have passed since the later of the date payment was due and the date of supply. Agreeing an extended due date restarts that clock from the extended date — and a customer entering administration does not bring it forward.
- For supplies before 19 March 1997, ownership must have passed; that condition no longer applies to modern supplies.
Claim the VAT fraction of the unpaid balance in Box 4 of the return covering the period you first become entitled — for a standard-rated supply, the fraction is one-sixth of the VAT-inclusive unpaid amount. The right to claim expires 4 years and 6 months after the later of the due date and the supply date. Keep the invoices and the bad debt account records for 4 years from the claim, alongside the standard 6-year VAT record duty. You cannot issue a credit note simply because a customer has not paid — credit notes are only for genuine mistakes, overcharges or agreed reductions. If the customer later pays, repay the corresponding VAT in Box 1 of the return covering the receipt. [Source 2]
Under cash accounting, none of this is needed while you remain in the scheme: Notice 700/18 itself notes that cash accountants only pay VAT on amounts actually received, so bad debt relief is unnecessary. The relief only becomes relevant if you leave the scheme with unpaid invoices outstanding. [Source 2]
The other side of the coin: the s.26A clawback
The 6-month rule cuts both ways. Under section 26A, a customer who reclaimed input VAT on a purchase invoice must repay that input tax if the supplier is still unpaid 6 months after the relevant date — the supply date, or the later due date for payment. There is no supplier notification for modern supplies: you must monitor your own aged creditors. Only the unpaid element is repaid, and if you later pay the supplier, the input tax can be reclaimed again in the period of payment. An extra-statutory concession relieves businesses where insolvency proceedings began after the supply but before the repayment fell due. [Source 2][Source 4]
This is the trap for "pay-when-paid" arrangements: an agency that withholds payment from a contractor because its own client has not paid can find itself repaying input VAT at exactly the moment its cash flow is frozen. Under cash accounting, the clawback cannot arise for scheme transactions, because the input tax was never claimed before payment. [Source 2]
Leaving the scheme: the cliff edge
You can only leave at the end of a tax period, whether voluntarily or because you crossed £1.6 million. On leaving, all outstanding VAT comes into account — output VAT on unpaid sales invoices, less unclaimed input VAT on unpaid purchase invoices. You have two choices: [Source 1]
- Account for everything in the final scheme period. Simpler, but potentially a severe cash-flow shock if receivables are high.
- Take a further 6 months to account for pre-exit invoices on a cash basis as payments arrive, with any balance still unpaid at the end of that window brought into account then. You do not need to tell HMRC which route you chose.
The rapid-growth trap: the 6-month option is barred if HMRC withdrew the scheme from you, or if rolling 12-month supplies exceeded £1.6 million and supplies in the previous 3 months alone exceeded £1.35 million. If you deregister, there is no 6-month option at all: the final return, due within 2 months of deregistration, must account for all outstanding VAT — though bad debt relief can then be claimed on qualifying debts. Voluntary VAT deregistration and the £88,000 threshold [Source 1][Source 5]
If you leave voluntarily or through the ceiling, you may rejoin from the start of a later tax period provided you are eligible again. [Source 1]
Transactions that must stay on standard accounting
Cash accounting must be applied to your whole VAT-registered business, but these transactions are excluded and stay on invoice-date rules: [Source 1]
- Goods bought or sold under lease purchase, hire purchase, conditional sale or credit sale agreements.
- Goods imported, acquired from an EU member state, or removed from a customs warehouse or free zone.
- Supplies subject to a domestic reverse charge.
- Supplies where you issue a VAT invoice and payment is not due in full within 6 months of the invoice date.
- Supplies where you issue a VAT invoice in advance of making the supply.
Construction reverse charge. Where a subcontractor supplies construction services to a VAT-registered contractor who is not an end user, the subcontractor charges no VAT and the contractor self-accounts. Because those supplies are excluded from cash accounting, a construction business on the scheme runs a split system: reverse-charge work on invoice dates, everything else on payment dates. HMRC itself warns that for subcontractors whose sales are mostly reverse-charge, cash accounting may not benefit them — standard accounting recovers input VAT on materials at invoice date instead of waiting until merchants are paid. [Source 1]
Other schemes. Cash accounting can be combined with annual accounting, but not with the flat rate scheme (which has its own cash-based method). Annual accounting is available up to £1.35 million of expected taxable turnover, with one annual return and instalments through the year, and an exit above £1.6 million. The flat rate scheme is for turnover up to £150,000 excluding VAT, with exit if annual income exceeds £230,000. How the flat rate scheme compares [Source 1][Source 6][Source 7]
Worked example: slow payment, part payment, then a bad debt
All figures are illustrative. Sarah is a freelance marketing consultant in Leeds, England, VAT-registered on quarterly returns, making only standard-rated supplies. In her September 2026 quarter she issues a sales invoice for £1,200 including VAT (£1,000 plus £200 output VAT), payment due 15 October 2026, and receives a supplier invoice for £600 including VAT (£500 plus £100 input VAT). Neither invoice is paid by 30 September. [Source 1][Source 2]
Step 1: the September quarter. Under standard accounting, Sarah's September return shows £200 output VAT less £100 input VAT — £100 payable to HMRC, although no cash has moved. Under cash accounting, the September return shows £0: neither transaction has been paid. [Source 1]
Step 2: a part payment. On 10 December 2026 the customer part-pays £780. Under cash accounting, £780 is 65% of the £1,200 invoice, so 65% of the £200 VAT — £130 — is declared in the December quarter, and £70 remains deferred. Under standard accounting, the £200 was already paid in September; the receipt changes nothing. [Source 1]
Step 3: the balance never arrives. The remaining £420 (including £70 of VAT) is never paid. Under standard accounting, Sarah writes the debt off to her bad debt account and, from 15 April 2027 — 6 months after the 15 October 2026 due date — claims £70 of bad debt relief in Box 4 (£420 × one-sixth). Under cash accounting, the £70 is simply never declared. Either way the VAT ultimately borne on this invoice is £130; the difference is entirely timing and cash flow. [Source 2]
The mirror image. If Sarah herself leaves the £600 supplier invoice unpaid for more than 6 months after its relevant date under standard accounting, she must repay the £100 input tax she claimed — and can reclaim it if she later pays. Under cash accounting she would never have claimed it in the first place. [Source 2][Source 4]
VAT on Sarah's £1,200 invoice, as cash arrives
VAT on Sarah's £1,200 invoice, as cash arrives
A £780 part payment declares £130 of the £200 VAT; the remaining £70 is deferred under cash accounting, or recovered later as bad debt relief under standard accounting.
| Stage | Standard accounting | Cash accounting |
|---|---|---|
| September quarter (nothing paid) | £200 output − £100 input = £100 payable | £0 declared |
| 10 December 2026 (£780 part-paid) | No change (£200 already paid) | £130 declared (65% of £200) |
| Balance £420 never paid | £70 bad debt relief from 15 April 2027 | £70 never declared |
| Total VAT on the invoice | £130 (£200 − £70 relief) | £130 (£130 declared) |
Sarah's invoice: from issue to bad debt relief
Sarah's invoice: from issue to bad debt relief
Standard accounting pays the VAT up front and recovers it months later; cash accounting only ever taxes cash received.
Which profile fits which method?
| Business profile | Recommended method | Why |
|---|---|---|
| B2B suppliers giving 30–90 day credit, usually owing HMRC net VAT | Cash accounting | No pre-funding of output VAT; automatic bad debt protection |
| Agencies with "pay-when-paid" contractor terms | Cash accounting | Avoids both unpaid-client output VAT and the s.26A clawback on unpaid contractors |
| Retail, e-commerce and point-of-sale hospitality | Standard accounting | Paid immediately, so no deferral to gain; cash accounting only delays input reclaims |
| Exporters, zero-rated producers, capital-heavy start-ups in a repayment position | Standard accounting | Input VAT refunded on invoice receipt, before suppliers are paid |
| Construction subcontractors working mainly under the reverse charge | Standard accounting | Reverse-charge sales carry no output VAT; standard accounting recovers materials VAT at invoice date |
| Fast-growing businesses approaching £1.35 million–£1.6 million | Standard accounting (or a planned transition) | Avoids the exit cliff edge and the loss of the 6-month window |
Common mistakes
Choosing by habit, not by payment profile. The test is your customers' payment speed against your own, plus whether you usually owe or reclaim — not which method your software defaults to. [Source 1]
Forgetting the input side. Cash accounting delays reclaims as well as payments. If suppliers give you longer credit than you give customers, standard accounting can leave you better off. [Source 1]
Using the wrong payment date. Card VAT counts on the voucher date, not settlement; cheque VAT counts on the later of receipt and the cheque date. Getting either wrong misstates the period. [Source 1]
Issuing a credit note for non-payment. A credit note cannot cancel VAT on an unpaid debt — only the bad debt relief route, with its write-off and 6-month wait, can. [Source 2]
Ignoring the s.26A clock as a customer. You must track unpaid supplier invoices yourself; no one notifies you, and the repayment falls due 6 months after the relevant date whether or not your supplier claims relief. [Source 2][Source 4]
Leaving the scheme unplanned. Exiting with a large unpaid sales ledger creates an immediate VAT bill on money you have not received — plan the 6-month option before you cross £1.6 million, and check the 3-month trap. [Source 1]
Applying cash accounting to excluded transactions. Reverse-charge supplies, hire-purchase goods, imports and invoices not due within 6 months stay on invoice-date rules even while the rest of the business is on cash accounting. [Source 1]
Frequently asked questions
Can I join cash accounting part-way through a VAT period?
No. You start from the beginning of your next VAT period, and you cannot backdate the scheme. Separate pre-scheme invoices in your records so they are not taxed twice. [Source 1]
Can I use cash accounting and the flat rate scheme together?
No. The flat rate scheme has its own cash-based method, and the two cannot be combined. Cash accounting can, however, be combined with annual accounting. [Source 1][Source 7]
A customer pays by card. When do I account for the VAT?
On the date you make out the sales voucher, not when the card provider settles the funds to you. If the card payment is dishonoured, no VAT is due — or adjust if already accounted for. [Source 1]
What happens if my turnover passes £1.6 million?
You must leave at the end of your current tax period and account for all outstanding VAT, either at once or over a further 6 months — unless HMRC withdrew the scheme or your previous 3 months alone exceeded £1.35 million, in which case the 6-month option is barred. [Source 1]
Do I ever need bad debt relief if I am on cash accounting?
Not while you remain in the scheme — unpaid sales never enter the return. Relief matters when you leave with unpaid invoices, or for any supplies accounted for outside the scheme. [Source 1][Source 2]
Can I reclaim VAT on a supplier invoice I have not paid yet?
Under cash accounting, no — only when you pay. Under standard accounting, yes on receipt of the invoice, but you must repay it under s.26A if the supplier is still unpaid 6 months after the relevant date. [Source 1][Source 2][Source 4]
Sources
Numbers in square brackets refer to the sources below. All accessed 29 October 2026.
- HMRC, VAT Notice 731: Cash Accounting Scheme — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC, VAT Notice 700/18: Relief from VAT on bad debts — (opens external site) ↩
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 36 — (opens external site) ↩
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 26A — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC, VAT Notice 700/11: Cancelling your registration — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC, VAT Notice 732: Annual Accounting Scheme — (opens external site) ↩
- HMRC, VAT Notice 733: Flat Rate Scheme for small businesses — (opens external site) ↩
Please note: This article is general information about UK tax rules, not personal financial advice. Which VAT accounting method suits you depends on your full circumstances, including how quickly customers pay, whether you usually owe or reclaim VAT, and whether your supplies fall under the domestic reverse charge. Figures are stated for 2026/27 unless another period is given, and thresholds and rates can change at future fiscal events.
Please note: This article is general information only, based on our understanding of the rules at the date it was last updated. It is not advice and should not be relied on for your own circumstances. Rules and rates change, so please speak to us or another qualified adviser before acting.
Want to talk it through?
Email us with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we’ll get back to you to arrange a free consultation.
Book a free consultation