Landlords and property

Does Section 24 push landlords into the High Income Child Benefit Charge?

Because residential mortgage interest is no longer deductible, a landlord's adjusted net income for Child Benefit purposes is higher than their cash position suggests — and the Section 24 tax reduction does nothing to bring it down.

Short answer: yes, it can — and the mechanism is structural, not a quirk. Since 2020-21, residential mortgage interest has not been deductible when working out taxable property profits, so the interest is added back in full. A landlord's adjusted net income for High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) purposes is therefore higher than their cash position suggests. And because the Section 24 relief is a tax reduction applied at the end of the tax calculation, it does nothing to bring adjusted net income back down.[Source 1][Source 2][Source 10]

The result: a landlord with a modest cash profit can find their adjusted net income pushed over the £60,000 HICBC threshold, and start repaying Child Benefit they thought they were safely below.[Source 10]

How is adjusted net income worked out for HICBC?

The charge is set out in Chapter 8 of Part 10 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, and it turns entirely on one figure: adjusted net income.[Source 6]

Adjusted net income is defined in section 58 of the Income Tax Act 2007. In practice, GOV.UK describes it as your total taxable income — including savings interest and dividends — calculated before any Personal Allowances, less pension contributions and Gift Aid.[Source 4][Source 10]

Following the section 23 calculation order, that means:

  • Step 1 — total income: all taxable income streams are added together, including property business profits computed with finance costs disallowed.[Source 1][Source 3]
  • Step 2 — net income: specific reliefs against total income are deducted. Adjusted net income is derived from this Step 2 figure.[Source 3][Source 4]
  • Then the section 58 adjustments: deduct the gross amount of personal pension contributions made under relief at source, and the grossed-up amount of Gift Aid donations.[Source 4][Source 10][Source 14]

Two consequences matter for landlords. First, the £12,570 Personal Allowance is not deducted before the HICBC test — adjusted net income is a before-allowance figure, so a salary of £52,000 plus taxable property profit of £15,000 gives adjusted net income of £67,000 regardless of allowances.[Source 10][Source 13] Second, nothing in the section 58 adjustments touches finance costs: there is no deduction for mortgage interest at any point in the adjusted-net-income computation.[Source 1][Source 4]

Why doesn't the Section 24 tax reduction help?

Before Section 24, mortgage interest was deductible as a business expense, so the rental profit entering Step 1 reflected cash earnings. Section 24 of the Finance (No. 2) Act 2015 changed that in two moves.[Source 7][Source 18]

First, section 272A of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005 prohibits any deduction for interest and other finance costs in computing the profits of a residential property business. Gross rent less operating costs enters Step 1 unreduced by mortgage interest.[Source 1]

Second, sections 274A and 274AA give relief for those disallowed costs as a basic-rate tax reduction. That reduction is deducted at Step 6 of the section 23 calculation — it reduces the tax bill, not taxable income.[Source 2][Source 3]

Section 23 stepWhat happensEffect on adjusted net income
Step 1: Total incomeAll taxable income added, including property profits computed with finance costs disallowedSets the inflated starting figure
Step 2: Net incomeSpecific reliefs deductedThis is the figure adjusted net income is derived from
Step 3: AllowancesPersonal Allowances deductedNo effect — adjusted net income is before allowances
Steps 4–5: Tax chargedTax calculated on taxable incomeProcedural only
Step 6: Tax reductionsThe section 274A finance-cost reduction is deducted here (20% through 2026-27; 24% from 2027-28)No effect — four steps too late to change adjusted net income

Because adjusted net income is fixed at Step 2 and the finance-cost credit lands at Step 6, the credit can never pull a landlord back below the £60,000 threshold. HMRC works through the restriction and its carry-forward in manual PIM2058.[Source 2][Source 8]

A worked example

Consider Alex (illustrative), an individual landlord resident in England, for 2025-26. All assumptions are stated; the example is illustrative, not advice.

  • Employment income: £52,000 gross salary under PAYE.
  • One residential property let on an assured shorthold tenancy: £18,000 gross annual rent.
  • Allowable operating expenses (insurance, gas safety, repairs, agency fees; excluding finance costs): £3,000.
  • Mortgage finance costs on an interest-only buy-to-let mortgage: £9,600 a year.
  • Two qualifying children; the household claims Child Benefit. Alex's partner earns £28,000, so Alex is the higher earner.

Child Benefit rates for 2025-26

For 2025-26 the weekly rates are £26.05 for the eldest or only child and £17.25 for each additional child. For two children over 52 weeks that is (£26.05 + £17.25) × 52 = £43.30 × 52 = £2,251.60 a year.[Source 12] For 2026-27 the rates rise to £27.05 and £17.90, giving (£27.05 + £17.90) × 52 = £2,337.40 for two children.[Source 11][Source 12]

Step (a): Rental profit with interest added back

Under section 272A, the £9,600 of finance costs cannot be deducted:

  • Gross rental income: £18,000
  • Less allowable expenses: (£3,000)
  • Taxable property profit: £18,000 − £3,000 = £15,000

The actual cash profit is very different: £15,000 less £9,600 interest = £5,400.

Step (b): Adjusted net income before and after the restriction

Before Section 24, when interest was deductible, Alex's adjusted net income would have been £52,000 + £5,400 = £57,400 — below the £60,000 threshold, so no charge and the full £2,251.60 retained.

Under Section 24, the taxable profit of £15,000 enters Step 1 instead: £52,000 + £15,000 = £67,000. Alex's adjusted net income is £9,600 higher — exactly the interest paid away — breaching the threshold by £7,000 despite a cash profit of only £5,400.[Source 1][Source 10]

Adjusted net income bridge, 2025-26Amount
Employment salary£52,000
Gross rental receipts£18,000
Allowable operating expenses(£3,000)
Taxable property profit (section 272A basis)£15,000
Mortgage finance costs deducted£0 — disallowed
Step 2 net income£67,000
Section 58 deductions (no pension or Gift Aid)£0
Adjusted net income£67,000

Alex's adjusted net income: before and after Section 24

Alex's adjusted net income: before and after Section 24The £9,600 of mortgage interest added back lifts adjusted net income from £57,400 to £67,000, across the £60,000 High Income Child Benefit Charge threshold. The Section 24 tax reduction does not move either bar.Before Section 24£57,400£57,400After Section 24£67,000£67,000Alex's adjusted net income: before and after Section 24The £9,600 of mortgage interest added back lifts adjusted net income from £57,400 to £67,000, across the £60,000 High Income Child Benefit Charge threshold. The Section 24 tax reduction does not move either bar.Before Section 24£57,400£57,400After Section 24£67,000£67,000

Alex's adjusted net income: before and after Section 24. The £9,600 of mortgage interest added back lifts adjusted net income from £57,400 to £67,000 — across the £60,000 HICBC threshold. Sources: [Source 1][Source 10].

Step (c): The charge at the taper

The charge is 1% of Child Benefit for every £200 of adjusted net income over £60,000:[Source 10]

  • Excess over threshold: £67,000 − £60,000 = £7,000
  • Taper percentage: £7,000 ÷ £200 = 35%
  • Charge: 35% × £2,251.60 = £788.06, payable via Self Assessment.

Alex repays £788.06 solely because of the interest add-back.

Adjusted net incomeExcess over £60,000ClawbackAnnual charge (two children, £2,251.60)Child Benefit retained
£60,000 or below£00%£0.00£2,251.60 (100%)
£62,000£2,00010%£225.16£2,026.44 (90%)
£65,000£5,00025%£562.90£1,688.70 (75%)
£67,000 (Alex, no pension)£7,00035%£788.06£1,463.54 (65%)
£70,000£10,00050%£1,125.80£1,125.80 (50%)
£75,000£15,00075%£1,688.70£562.90 (25%)
£80,000 or above£20,000+100%£2,251.60£0.00 (0%)

Step (d): Pension contribution mitigation — and the finance-cost credit

If Alex makes a gross personal pension contribution of £8,000 (paid as £6,400 net cash under relief at source, grossed up by 20%): £67,000 − £8,000 = £59,000, below the threshold, so the charge falls to £0 and the full £2,251.60 is kept.[Source 4][Source 10]

Separately, Alex is entitled to the section 274A tax reduction on the £9,600 of finance costs:

  • For 2025-26 and 2026-27 at the 20% basic rate: 20% × £9,600 = £1,920, deducted from the tax bill at Step 6.
  • From 2027-28 at the 24% property basic rate announced at Budget 2026 (replacing the 22% legislated in Finance Act 2026): 24% × £9,600 = £2,304 — £384 more, but still a Step 6 reduction.[Source 15][Source 16]

The credit cuts Alex's income tax. It does nothing to the £67,000 adjusted net income, and therefore nothing to the Child Benefit charge.[Source 2]

What if the property is jointly owned?

Joint ownership splits the property profit — and therefore the HICBC exposure — between the owners, because the charge is assessed on each individual, not on the household total.[Source 10]

For spouses and civil partners living together, section 836 of the Income Tax Act 2007 treats income from jointly held property as owned in equal shares (50:50), even if the underlying capital shares are unequal. The 50:50 rule can be disapplied only by a Form 17 declaration under section 837, which requires the couple to hold the property as beneficial tenants in common in unequal shares (evidenced by a Declaration of Trust) and to submit the form to HMRC within 60 days of signing it. HMRC explains the rule in manual TSEM9814.[Source 5][Source 9]

For unmarried couples, business partners or siblings, section 836 does not apply: profits and finance costs follow actual beneficial ownership, with no Form 17 needed.[Source 5]

The planning effect is real. Take a couple where Partner A earns £55,500 and Partner B earns £28,000, with a property producing £15,000 of taxable profit:

  • 50:50 split: Partner A gets £7,500, so adjusted net income is £55,500 + £7,500 = £63,000 — excess £3,000, a 15% clawback (£337.74 on two children's £2,251.60). Partner B is at £35,500. Partner A, as the higher earner, pays.
  • 90:10 split in Partner B's favour (Declaration of Trust plus a valid Form 17): Partner A gets £1,500, so adjusted net income is £57,000; Partner B gets £13,500, so £41,500. Neither partner is over £60,000, and no charge arises.

Restructuring ownership purely to dodge the charge needs proper advice — the Declaration of Trust has capital gains, inheritance tax and mortgage implications of its own — but the HICBC arithmetic is why the split matters.[Source 5][Source 9]

Pension contributions and Gift Aid as mitigations

Because section 58 deducts pension contributions and Gift Aid in arriving at adjusted net income, both are genuine mitigations for the Section 24 add-back.[Source 4]

Pensions. Under relief at source, a net cash contribution is grossed up by 20%, and the gross amount is deducted from net income: every £1 of gross pension contribution reduces adjusted net income by £1. Salary sacrifice works the same way from the other direction — by exchanging salary for employer pension contributions, gross employment earnings fall before they ever enter Step 1.[Source 4][Source 10]

Gift Aid. A cash donation to a UK registered charity is grossed up by basic-rate tax (a £100 donation becomes £125 gross) and the grossed-up amount is deducted from net income. And Gift Aid has a timing trick pensions do not: in a Self Assessment return you can claim tax relief on donations made in the current tax year, up to the date you send the return, against the previous tax year — provided you do not miss the return deadline. A landlord who only discovers on finalising rental accounts that the prior year breached £60,000 can still act.[Source 14]

Opting out vs paying the charge

At £80,000 and above the taper reaches 100%, so the household repays everything it received. At that point, and often below it, families weigh receiving payments and repaying them against opting out.[Source 10]

FeatureOpting out of paymentsReceiving payments and paying the charge
ChargeNone — no payments are issuedUp to 100% of Child Benefit received
Self AssessmentNo return needed solely for the chargeThe higher earner must file (or pay via PAYE if eligible and no return is otherwise needed)
National Insurance creditsPreserved in full — the claim stays activePreserved in full
Child's National Insurance numberIssued automatically before age 16Issued automatically before age 16
Cash flowNothing received, nothing to repayCash received during the year, repaid as a balancing payment
ReversibilityPayments can be restarted at any time via the online service or the Child Benefit Office; the office will confirm any backdated payments dueAdjusts automatically on filing each year

The one mistake to avoid is not claiming at all. A non-working parent who never claims loses the National Insurance credits that protect their State Pension record. The correct approach for a high-income household is to claim, but elect not to receive payments: credits and the child's National Insurance number are protected, and no charge arises.[Source 10]

Common mistakes

  • Assuming the finance-cost credit reduces adjusted net income. It is a Step 6 tax reduction, not an income deduction. It cuts tax, never the HICBC measure.[Source 2]
  • Forgetting the charge falls on the higher earner. An employed partner earning £65,000 with no property at all is liable if their partner receives Child Benefit; equally, a landlord whose salary is £50,000 but whose Section 24 add-back lifts adjusted net income to £65,000 becomes the liable partner.[Source 6][Source 10]
  • Missing that opting out preserves National Insurance credits. Families avoid claiming entirely to dodge the tax system, and the non-working parent loses credits. Claim and opt out instead.[Source 10]
  • Confusing the thresholds. £50,270 is the higher-rate threshold in England, Wales and Northern Ireland; £60,000 is where HICBC starts; £80,000 is where it reaches 100%; £100,000 is where the Personal Allowance tapers away (£1 per £2 of adjusted net income, to zero at £125,140). A landlord at £67,000 pays higher-rate tax and a 35% HICBC clawback, but keeps the full £12,570 Personal Allowance.[Source 10][Source 13]

Frequently asked questions

Does Section 24 apply if rental properties are held within a limited company?

No. Section 272A applies to unincorporated landlords taxed under Income Tax. A company deducts interest under the Corporation Tax loan relationship rules instead, and rental income retained in the company does not enter any individual's adjusted net income unless extracted as salary or dividends.[Source 1]

How does HICBC apply if a couple separates during the tax year?

The charge follows the period you lived together as partners: it applies from the date you move in together until the date you permanently separate or Child Benefit payments stop. Annual adjusted net income still sets the clawback percentage, but it applies only to the benefit received during the period of partnership.[Source 10]

Can unused Section 24 finance-cost relief be carried forward to future years?

Yes. If the tax reduction cannot be fully used in a year — because property profits or total income are insufficient — the unrelieved amount carries forward indefinitely while the property business continues, as explained in our article on carrying forward unused Section 24 relief. But it remains a Step 6 tax reduction when eventually used, so it will never reduce adjusted net income in a future year either.[Source 2][Source 8]

What happens from 6 April 2027 when the property tax rates change?

Property income will be charged at dedicated property rates — 24% basic, 44% higher and 49% additional. The finance-cost tax credit will be calculated at the new 24% property basic rate, up from 20%. That increases the credit but does not change its nature: it stays a Step 6 reduction and still does not lower adjusted net income.[Source 15][Source 16]

Can a landlord claim both the £1,000 Property Allowance and the Section 24 tax credit?

No. If you claim the property allowance, you cannot deduct any allowable expenses or claim any other allowances — so you must choose between deducting actual expenses alongside the finance-cost reduction, or claiming the flat £1,000 allowance against gross receipts.[Source 17]

If payments were stopped, can Child Benefit be restarted?

Yes. If you previously opted out because of the tax charge and still qualify, you can restart payments via the online service or by contacting the Child Benefit Office. The office will confirm any backdated payments due, and any charge on benefit received from the restart date applies if adjusted net income is over the threshold.[Source 10]

Book a free consultation

If Section 24 has pushed your household over the Child Benefit threshold, or you are weighing pension contributions, Gift Aid or an ownership split against the charge, we can help. See our services. Email us at contact@taxnetwork.uk with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we'll call you back as soon as possible. There's no charge and no obligation.

Want to know more? Read Carrying forward unused Section 24 relief: how it works, Property pooling for landlords: how multiple lets are taxed and Can I deduct mortgage interest from rental income? UK guide.

About this article. We review it after each Budget, and when finance-cost relief, the property basic rate, Child Benefit rates or the HICBC thresholds change.

Disclaimer: This article is general information about UK tax as it stood when it was written and checked (see the date above). It is not advice for your circumstances and does not create a client relationship. Rules change, so check the sources below or speak to a qualified adviser before acting.

Written and checked in October 2026. Figures and sources were correct at that date; tax rules change, so check the current position or ask us.

Sources

Numbers in square brackets in the article link to the sources below.

All accessed 29 October 2026.

  1. Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, section 272A (restricting deductions for finance costs related to residential property) — (opens external site) ↩
  2. Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, sections 274A and 274AA (tax reduction for individuals: non-deductible costs of a dwelling-related loan; brought-forward amounts) — (opens external site) ↩
  3. Income Tax Act 2007, section 23 (income tax calculation: Steps 1–6) — (opens external site) ↩
  4. Income Tax Act 2007, section 58 (adjusted net income) — (opens external site) ↩
  5. Income Tax Act 2007, sections 836 and 837 (jointly held property: 50:50 rule and Form 17 declarations) — (opens external site) ↩
  6. Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, Part 10 Chapter 8 (High Income Child Benefit Charge) — (opens external site) ↩
  7. Finance (No. 2) Act 2015, section 24 (relief for finance costs related to residential property businesses) — (opens external site) ↩
  8. HMRC Property Income Manual, PIM2058 (finance-cost restriction: five-step calculation, adjusted total income, carry-forward) — (opens external site) ↩
  9. HMRC Trusts, Settlements and Estates Manual, TSEM9814 (property held jointly by married couples or civil partners: the 50:50 rule) — (opens external site) ↩
  10. GOV.UK, High Income Child Benefit Charge — (opens external site) ↩
  11. GOV.UK, Child Benefit: what you'll get (2026-27 rates: £27.05 eldest, £17.90 additional) — (opens external site) ↩
  12. GOV.UK, Child Benefit, Guardian's Allowance and tax credits — rates and allowances (2025-26: £26.05/£17.25; 2026-27: £27.05/£17.90) — (opens external site) ↩
  13. GOV.UK, Income Tax rates and Personal Allowances — (opens external site) ↩
  14. GOV.UK, Tax relief when you donate to a charity: Gift Aid (25p per £1 gross-up; claiming current-year donations against the previous year) — (opens external site) ↩
  15. GOV.UK, Change to tax rates for property, savings and dividend income: technical note (relief for residential finance costs at the property basic rate) — (opens external site) ↩
  16. GOV.UK, Budget 2026: Overview of tax legislation and rates (property rates 24/44/49% from 6 April 2027, announced; to be legislated in Finance Bill 2026-27) — (opens external site) ↩
  17. HMRC, UK property notes (SA105 notes) — (opens external site) ↩
  18. GOV.UK, Changes to tax relief for residential landlords: how it's worked out, including case studies — (opens external site) ↩

Please note: This article is general information only, based on our understanding of the rules at the date it was last updated. It is not advice and should not be relied on for your own circumstances. Rules and rates change, so please speak to us or another qualified adviser before acting.

Please note: This article is general information only, based on our understanding of the rules at the date it was last updated. It is not advice and should not be relied on for your own circumstances. Rules and rates change, so please speak to us or another qualified adviser before acting.

Want to talk it through?

Email us with a line about what you need and a good time to reach you, and we’ll get back to you to arrange a free consultation.

Book a free consultation